Ep. 36 Revisiting the "Vaccinate Or Mask" Controversy

09/11/20 • 50 min

We look back at a pre-COVID controversy in which nurses' unions fought against mandatory mask policies and won. Everyone seems to have forgotten about this, but obviously it is relevant to the situation today. Also, we talk about the growing body of evidence showing the lockdowns were ineffective.
Alex Berenson in Threadreader, Aug 7, 2020: "The Ontario arbitration fight about masks is really stunning..."

CBC, Jan 8, 2014: Nurses gear up for fight over mandatory flu shots or masks

CBC, Sep 10, 2015: Union says Ontario nurses can't be forced to wear masks in flu season
CBC, Dec 4, 2019: B.C. nurses no longer need to get flu vaccine or wear masks, can rely on 'professional judgment'
CanLII, Dec 16, 2015: Bloorview School Authority v Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 4400
CanLII, Nov 9,2016: William Osler Health System v Ontario Nurses’ Association, 2016
New York Post, Jun 6, 2020: WHO reverses position on face masks as coronavirus cases climb
Donald L. Luskin in The Wall Street Journal, Sep 1, 2020: The Failed Experiment of Covid Lockdowns
Daily Mail, Jul 23, 2020: Lockdowns DON'T work, study claims: Researchers say stay-at-home orders made no difference to coronavirus deaths around the world - but prior health levels DID
Lancet via EClinicalMedicine, Jul 21, 2020: A country level analysis measuring the impact of government actions, country preparedness and socioeconomic factors on COVID-19 mortality and related health outcomes
Irish Times, Sep 2, 2020: German lockdown was too harsh says health minister
Associated Press via USA Today, Sep 1, 2020: South Florida restaurants and casinos reopen as governor vows no more COVID-19 shutdowns
CBC, Sep 9, 2020: Alberta won't 'micromanage' businesses as COVID-19 infections climb: Kenney
Justice Centre News Release, Sep 9, 2020: Court ruling upholds Alberta bylaw that bans trailer signs on private land
Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens

Support the show

Support the show

Previous Episode

Ep. 35 A Permanent Loss of Rights?

Will the loss of freedom in Canada become permanent following the pandemic? Is it already permanent? We discuss possible remedies to this reduction of Charter rights and freedoms which is based on fear of COVID, a fear that governments and the media have stoked for months. Perhaps change will come when society fears the lockdown measures more than the virus.

John Carpay in The Post Millennial, Sep 1, 2020: COVID restrictions to Charter freedoms appear to be permanent

Amazon.ca: Escape from Freedom by Erich Fromm

RCI, Jul 21, 2020: Drug overdose deaths far exceed COVID-19 in British Columbia

South China Morning Post, Sep 2, 2020: Coronavirus death rate may be as bad – or worse – than for Spanish flu pandemic

Washington Post via National Post, Sep 1, 2020: 'It never went away': What the 1918 flu can tell us about when life might return to 'normal'

John Carpay in The Post Millennial, Jun 26, 2020: Jerry Dunham was killed by the lockdown—not by COVID-19

Justice Centre News Release, Apr 17, 2020: Trudeau and Premiers questioned about adverse consequences from government-imposed lockdowns

Global News, Sep 1, 2020: ‘I feel for parents’: Dr. Hinshaw regrets confusing COVID-19 orders as schools reopen

Justice Centre News Release, Aug 26, 2020: COVID Legislature Ticket Dropped; Complaint Submitted Regarding Alberta Sheriffs

Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens

Support the show (https://www.jccf.ca/donate/)

Next Episode

Ep. 37 The Saskatchewan Analysis

Lawyer Marty Moore joins us to go over the latest Justice Centre report, which is on the Saskatchewan government's response to COVID-19. Entitled "The Unjustified Persistence of Lockdowns," much of this work can be applied to other provinces as well.
Justice Centre News Release, Sep 14, 2020: Saskatchewan Government lockdown measures violate Charter: legal analysis
Justice Centre Report (PDF): The Unjustified Persistence of Lockdowns--A Charter Analysis of Saskatchewan’s Response to COVID-19
CTV, Mar 29, 2020: Don't head to your cottage to wait out COVID-19 pandemic, Canadians warned
Regina Leader-Post, Sep 12, 2020: A roadmap to Saskatchewan's pandemic election campaign
National Post, Sep 17, 2020: Ontario cuts social gathering numbers in three regions, brings in $10,000 fines for rule violators
CBC video via MSN, Sep 15, 2020: 'We're prepared for the worst,' Ontario health minister says [COVID Fatigue mentioned a 1:10]
Time, Apr 30, 2020: Are You Experiencing COVID-19 'Caution Fatigue?' Here's What It Is, and How to Fight It
Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens

Support the show

If you like this episode you’ll love

Stay Tuned with Preet

Pod Save the People

Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast

Aspen Ideas to Go

The Gray Area with Sean Illing

Episode Comments

Generate a badge

Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode

Select type & size

Copy