
The CauseHealth Series: Chapter 9 - Causality and Dispositionality in Medical Practice with Prof. Ivor Ralph Edwards
02/12/21 • 46 min
Welcome to another episode of The Words Matter Podcast.
In this episode of the CauseHealth Series I'm speaking with Professor Ivor Ralph Edwards about his Chapter 9 of the CauseHealth book (download for FREE here) titled Causality and Dispositionality in Medical Practice (read his chapter here). Ralph is Professor of Medicine and Senior Advisor (and Former Director) at the Uppsala Monitoring Centre, the WHO Collaborating Centre for International Drug Monitoring.
He has worked in clinical toxicology in the fields of drug abuse, acute and chronic poisoning, toxicity from industrial chemicals as well as adverse drug reactions. He now works on medical and legal aspects of causality evaluation, as well as issues of risk and benefit evaluation and data mining approaches to support signal detection and evaluation.
In this episode we talk about:
- Ralph’s view of causation early in his career as a medical career.
- His role in leading the global work to improve clinical reporting on possible side-effects.
- We talk about how when working on medicine safety globally, he sees that different dispositions in different population groups affect how they response to medicines.
- Ralph gives us examples from his own clinical work where some of the dispositionalist features of causality have been important.
- We discuss the time it takes for a causal story to emerge.
- Finally we discuss the problem of relying too much on quantitative evidence and statistics to measure and standardise medical practice and treatments.
It was pleasure speaking with Ralph. He has a vast and varied experience in medicine, and it was great to hear the role that causal dispositionalism has played in his work. His many anecdotes, great sense of humour and a voice for a podcasting, made the conversation all the more enjoyable.
If you liked the podcast, you'll love The Words Matter online course and mentoring to develop you clinical practice - ideal for all MSK therapists.
Follow Words Matter on:
Instagram @Wordsmatter_education @TheWordsMatterPodcast
Twitter @WordsClinical
Facebook Words Matter - Improving Clinical Communication
★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★Welcome to another episode of The Words Matter Podcast.
In this episode of the CauseHealth Series I'm speaking with Professor Ivor Ralph Edwards about his Chapter 9 of the CauseHealth book (download for FREE here) titled Causality and Dispositionality in Medical Practice (read his chapter here). Ralph is Professor of Medicine and Senior Advisor (and Former Director) at the Uppsala Monitoring Centre, the WHO Collaborating Centre for International Drug Monitoring.
He has worked in clinical toxicology in the fields of drug abuse, acute and chronic poisoning, toxicity from industrial chemicals as well as adverse drug reactions. He now works on medical and legal aspects of causality evaluation, as well as issues of risk and benefit evaluation and data mining approaches to support signal detection and evaluation.
In this episode we talk about:
- Ralph’s view of causation early in his career as a medical career.
- His role in leading the global work to improve clinical reporting on possible side-effects.
- We talk about how when working on medicine safety globally, he sees that different dispositions in different population groups affect how they response to medicines.
- Ralph gives us examples from his own clinical work where some of the dispositionalist features of causality have been important.
- We discuss the time it takes for a causal story to emerge.
- Finally we discuss the problem of relying too much on quantitative evidence and statistics to measure and standardise medical practice and treatments.
It was pleasure speaking with Ralph. He has a vast and varied experience in medicine, and it was great to hear the role that causal dispositionalism has played in his work. His many anecdotes, great sense of humour and a voice for a podcasting, made the conversation all the more enjoyable.
If you liked the podcast, you'll love The Words Matter online course and mentoring to develop you clinical practice - ideal for all MSK therapists.
Follow Words Matter on:
Instagram @Wordsmatter_education @TheWordsMatterPodcast
Twitter @WordsClinical
Facebook Words Matter - Improving Clinical Communication
★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★Previous Episode

The CauseHealth Series: Chapter 8 - Above and Beyond Statistical Evidence. Why Stories Matter for Clinical Decisions and Shared Decision Making with Matthew Low
Welcome to another episode of The Words Matter Podcast.
So we continue our exploration of the CauseHealth book (download for FREE here), via this CauseHealth Series, and we have reached the midway point. In this episode I’m speaking with Matthew Low about his Chapter 8 titled Above and Beyond Statistical Evidence. Why Stories Matter for Clinical Decisions and Shared Decision Making (read Chapter 8 here).
Matthew is a Consultant Physiotherapist in the south of England, and is a Visiting Associate at the Orthopaedic Research Institute at Bournemouth University. Many of you will be aware of Matt’s excellent writing and thinking (see here, here and here), and he’s been on this podcast twice previously in episodes 7 (here) and 10 (here) about evidence, practice and knowledge.
In this episode we talk about;
- Matt’s journey into dispositonalism and CauseHealth.
- EBM in context of MSK practice and how has it shaped and impacted his practice.
- We talk about how a dispositionalist view of causation can frame the clinical questions and problems within MSK care.
- We talk about the role of clinical judgement; can we have too much? And who wins in a fight, evidence or judgement? And what to think and to do when these knowledge domains collide.
- We talk about stories OR statistics...or stories AND statistics, and how both forms of evidence can complement each other to give a vivid portrayal of the individual person and their story.
- We talk about the co-construction stories as a way of mutually identifying dispositions with the person
- And we talk about the practical/clinical consequences of adopting a dispositionalist perception on causation.
As expected, this was another hugely satisfying and insightful conversation with Matt, he has so much to offer on causality, evidence and person-centred care. His vast clinical experience, means that his perspective is very much ‘from the trenches’, making the theory all the more accessible and usable for clinicians. So please enjoy, and Matt will definitely be back in a Words Matter Quadrilogy later this year, so stand by.
Find Matthew on twitter via @MattLowPT
If you liked the podcast, you'll love The Words Matter online course and mentoring to develop you clinical practice - ideal for all MSK therapists.
Follow Words Matter on:
Instagram @Wordsmatter_education @TheWordsMatterPodcast
Twitter @WordsClinical
Facebook Words Matter - Improving Clinical Communication
★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★Next Episode

The CauseHealth Series: Chapter 10 - Lessons on Causality from Clinical Encounters with Severely Obese Patients with Dr Kai Brynjar Hagen
Welcome to another episode of the Words Matter Podcast.
On this episode of the CauseHealth Series, I’m speaking with Dr Kai Brynjar Hagen about his Chapter 10 that he wrote for the CauseHealth Book, titled ‘Lessons on Causality from Clinical Encounters with Severely Obese Patients’ (read Chapter 10 here).
Kai Brynjar is a Senior Consultant in the Regional Centre for Morbid Obesity, in the North Norway. He is also General Practitioner, District Medical Officer for Communicable Diseases and as you can imagine has his handful advising on the current pandemic.
He is Specialist in Community Medicine and is interested in ecological thinking in medicine, from the individual person to the policy level. And he is interested in primary causes of obesity development and factors that contribute to maintain obesity, such as trauma or other stressors (see his work here).
So in this chapter we talk about:
- The different roles that he has within the Norwegian healthcare system and how these relate to his thinking around causation.
- We talk about his view of causation in relation to obesity and how the biomedical view and diagnosis of obesity is insufficient to fully understand the whole person and the causal processes at play.
- Kai Brynjar contrasts the biomedical diagnosis of obesity (which focuses on medical symptoms such as diabetes or psychcobehavioural aspects such as diet or motivation for physical activity.
- We talk about how he strives for what he calls a ‘genuine’ causal diagnosis for severely obese patients.
- He tells us about the challenges of adopting a Whole Person Approach in larger structural and institutional settings which in he’s worked.
- We talk about about the main focus of his clinical encounters with obese patients, which is understand their life story- including their life as a child, and the centrality that this dialogue plays in the creation of a story together with the person.
So, this was another resonating conversation, with a clinician at the front line of helping people with complex causal stories. His compassion, warmth and sincere interest in obtaining a genuine understating of his patients’ causal story reverberated during our conversation.
So I bring you Dr Kai Brynjar Hagen.
If you liked the podcast, you'll love The Words Matter online course and mentoring to develop you clinical practice - ideal for all MSK therapists.
Follow Words Matter on:
Instagram @Wordsmatter_education @TheWordsMatterPodcast
Twitter @WordsClinical
Facebook Words Matter - Improving Clinical Communication
★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★If you like this episode you’ll love
Episode Comments
Generate a badge
Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode
<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/the-words-matter-podcast-with-oliver-thomson-130070/the-causehealth-series-chapter-9-causality-and-dispositionality-in-med-11761943"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to the causehealth series: chapter 9 - causality and dispositionality in medical practice with prof. ivor ralph edwards on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>
Copy