Log in

goodpods headphones icon

To access all our features

Open the Goodpods app
Close icon
Body of Crime - The Nashville Six - The Nashville Covenant Presbyterian School Active Shooter
plus icon
bookmark

The Nashville Six - The Nashville Covenant Presbyterian School Active Shooter

Explicit content warning

05/10/23 • 51 min

Body of Crime

Alright fellow crime lovers, today's case file is, “The Nashville Six (6) - School Shooting in the Capital of Country Music.” Please be advised that you will hear actual footage and viewer discretion is advised. As many of you have heard, an active shooter walked into the Covenant Presbyterian Church where they took the lives of six unsuspecting individuals that included three adults and three children.

An Active Shooting (also called a “Mass Shooting) is defined by the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as, and event in which one or more individuals are “actively engaged in killing or attempting to kill people in a populated area.” Implicit in this definition is the shooter’s use of a firearm. Though the FBI has not set a minimum number of casualties to qualify an event as a mass shooting, U.S. statute (the Investigative Assistance for Violent Crimes Act of 2012) defines a “mass killing” as “3 or more killings in a single incident.”

I want to start by sharing some key 2023 numbers with you (none of which include the killer(s)).

139 - this is the number of Mass Shooting attempts that have occurred to date

23 - this is the number of Mass Shooting Events that ended in three or more deaths

13 - this is the number of school shootings that occurred

13 - thats how many people were injured in a school shooting

10 - thats how many people (6 children and 4 adults) lost their lives in a school shooting

6 - thats how many lives were taken at the Covenant Presbyterian Church K-12 Private School in the Capital of Country Music‘s Nashville, TN

Monday, March 27th started like every other Monday for the last 14 years for Mike Hill, the custodian for Covenant Presbyterian Church and K-12 Private School. He smiled his larger than life smile and waved as the kids walked in, and began his day preparing to carry his vacuum cleaner up to the Sanctuary like he had done countless Monday’s before this one. His thoughts could have been on one of his seven children, or maybe one of his fourteen grandchildren. He loved to cook and spend time with family, so he may have been thinking about what he planned to cook for dinner when the shots reverberated through the quiet of the day, shattering the glass door. They called him Big Mike and he was a force to be reckoned with, but he would be the first of the six to fall.

Katherine Koonce was on a Zoom call in her office when she heard the first shots and the sound of breaking glass. She recognized it immediately. She had been a big advocate of Mass Shooter training and knew her staff was equipment to deal with anything that threatened her campus. She quickly dropped from the call, but she didn’t hide and she didn’t run. She walked out and met the shooter in the hallway where it is believed she attempted to engage the shooter directly. It was in her nature to be steadfast and be a protector of children. Covie, the unofficial school mascot that affectionately greeted the children daily, remained safely behind in her office. Covey would never see Katherine again.

It is unknown where the shooter encountered Cindy Peak, but those who knew the substitute teacher, knew that she had a passion for teaching and caring for children. Her last thoughts were most likely about her own three kids and her husband Chris, who would later state that he knew without a shadow of doubt that Cindy died protecting the children.

The three children who started their day as normal 9-year-old children often do...with a joyous spirit to learn and an innocence that would be memorialized in them forever at such a young age, could never understand how tragedy would devastate the community in the minutes, hours and days to come. All three were pronounced dead on arrival as they arrived at the hospital in ambulances. The doctors, helpless. The damage, catastrophic

Funeral / Service - April 4, 2023 - Mike Hill was just 61 years old (My father is 77!)

  • 100’s of Family, Friends, Co-Workers, Students, and members of the church were in attendance.
  • Pastor Jim Bachmann who presided over the service at Stephens Valley Church shared a beautiful sentiment, “He hugged my kids , and he knew them by name," Bachmann said. "As the first victim — maybe this is a sentimental thought, but it's a comfort to me to think that Mike was there to welcome the children through the pearly gates."
  • One of the few African American Church Members / Friends w/ Pastor who previously founded the Covenant Presbyterian Church, where the school was located.

Mrs. Koontz or Katherine who was 59 (just 9 years older than me) is believed to have been the second of the Nashville six to fall. Her body was positioned in the hallway where she laid in a way that led investigators to believe that a confrontation or struggle had ensued between hersel...

plus icon
bookmark

Alright fellow crime lovers, today's case file is, “The Nashville Six (6) - School Shooting in the Capital of Country Music.” Please be advised that you will hear actual footage and viewer discretion is advised. As many of you have heard, an active shooter walked into the Covenant Presbyterian Church where they took the lives of six unsuspecting individuals that included three adults and three children.

An Active Shooting (also called a “Mass Shooting) is defined by the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as, and event in which one or more individuals are “actively engaged in killing or attempting to kill people in a populated area.” Implicit in this definition is the shooter’s use of a firearm. Though the FBI has not set a minimum number of casualties to qualify an event as a mass shooting, U.S. statute (the Investigative Assistance for Violent Crimes Act of 2012) defines a “mass killing” as “3 or more killings in a single incident.”

I want to start by sharing some key 2023 numbers with you (none of which include the killer(s)).

139 - this is the number of Mass Shooting attempts that have occurred to date

23 - this is the number of Mass Shooting Events that ended in three or more deaths

13 - this is the number of school shootings that occurred

13 - thats how many people were injured in a school shooting

10 - thats how many people (6 children and 4 adults) lost their lives in a school shooting

6 - thats how many lives were taken at the Covenant Presbyterian Church K-12 Private School in the Capital of Country Music‘s Nashville, TN

Monday, March 27th started like every other Monday for the last 14 years for Mike Hill, the custodian for Covenant Presbyterian Church and K-12 Private School. He smiled his larger than life smile and waved as the kids walked in, and began his day preparing to carry his vacuum cleaner up to the Sanctuary like he had done countless Monday’s before this one. His thoughts could have been on one of his seven children, or maybe one of his fourteen grandchildren. He loved to cook and spend time with family, so he may have been thinking about what he planned to cook for dinner when the shots reverberated through the quiet of the day, shattering the glass door. They called him Big Mike and he was a force to be reckoned with, but he would be the first of the six to fall.

Katherine Koonce was on a Zoom call in her office when she heard the first shots and the sound of breaking glass. She recognized it immediately. She had been a big advocate of Mass Shooter training and knew her staff was equipment to deal with anything that threatened her campus. She quickly dropped from the call, but she didn’t hide and she didn’t run. She walked out and met the shooter in the hallway where it is believed she attempted to engage the shooter directly. It was in her nature to be steadfast and be a protector of children. Covie, the unofficial school mascot that affectionately greeted the children daily, remained safely behind in her office. Covey would never see Katherine again.

It is unknown where the shooter encountered Cindy Peak, but those who knew the substitute teacher, knew that she had a passion for teaching and caring for children. Her last thoughts were most likely about her own three kids and her husband Chris, who would later state that he knew without a shadow of doubt that Cindy died protecting the children.

The three children who started their day as normal 9-year-old children often do...with a joyous spirit to learn and an innocence that would be memorialized in them forever at such a young age, could never understand how tragedy would devastate the community in the minutes, hours and days to come. All three were pronounced dead on arrival as they arrived at the hospital in ambulances. The doctors, helpless. The damage, catastrophic

Funeral / Service - April 4, 2023 - Mike Hill was just 61 years old (My father is 77!)

  • 100’s of Family, Friends, Co-Workers, Students, and members of the church were in attendance.
  • Pastor Jim Bachmann who presided over the service at Stephens Valley Church shared a beautiful sentiment, “He hugged my kids , and he knew them by name," Bachmann said. "As the first victim — maybe this is a sentimental thought, but it's a comfort to me to think that Mike was there to welcome the children through the pearly gates."
  • One of the few African American Church Members / Friends w/ Pastor who previously founded the Covenant Presbyterian Church, where the school was located.

Mrs. Koontz or Katherine who was 59 (just 9 years older than me) is believed to have been the second of the Nashville six to fall. Her body was positioned in the hallway where she laid in a way that led investigators to believe that a confrontation or struggle had ensued between hersel...

Next Episode

undefined - Pre-Show Bonus: Who is Kitty & Jose Menendez (My Brother's Keeper - The Story of the Menendez Brothers)

Pre-Show Bonus: Who is Kitty & Jose Menendez (My Brother's Keeper - The Story of the Menendez Brothers)

Many of you may remember, if you’re about my age, the sensational news coverage of the Menendez brothers back in 1989. Those of you who were born after 1990, may have heard about it in news coverage over the years, but for those of you who have never heard about the gruesome and violent Hollywood murders, allow me to enlighten you.

On August 20th, 1989, Jose Menendez, a wealthy Hollywood executive and his stay at home wife, Kitty Menendez were gunned down in their Beverly Hills Mansion. Their two sons, Lyle Menendez who was 21 years old at the time and Erik Menendez, who was barely 18 found their parents murdered in cold blood when they returned home from a movie, or so the story went.

It would take months before both children would be arrested for the murder of their parents. At the time, the motive that splashed across newspaper headlines and television screens was, Greed. The boys had murdered their parents to inherit their millions, $16M to be more specific, almost $40M in today’s market.

The boys would stand two trials, the first ending in a hung jury. What was discovered during the first trial was an incredible and shocking family secret that impacted the jury making it impossible to give a guilty verdict. Both boys had been systematically and chronically emotionally, physically and sexually abused by their father...for years. All the way until the day of the murders. Their mother also contributed to their mental and physical abuse, but had been aware of the sexual abuse, which she never attempted to stop.

The same judge would preside over the 2nd trial, but he forbid any of the sexual abuse to be presented, dramatically swaying the proceeding and both boys were found guilty...both getting life sentences without the possibility of parole.

As we prepare for next week’s show titled, “My Brother’s Keeper”, the unfathomable story of the Menendez Brothers’ murders, we wanted to provide some insight into both Jose Menendez and Kitty Menendez’ lives as we struggle, even 34 years later, to understand what went wrong in this family, and you will be shocked at what we’ve discovered.

Prepare for insight into the Menendez family’s dark secrets as we dissect the Menendez family tree, from the crooked and broken branches down to the rotted roots.

Jose Enrique & Mary “Kitty” Louise Menendez

Jose Enrique Menendez

Early Life & Education

Episode Comments

Generate a badge

Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode

Select type & size
Open dropdown icon
share badge image

<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/body-of-crime-256222/the-nashville-six-the-nashville-covenant-presbyterian-school-active-sh-29782516"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to the nashville six - the nashville covenant presbyterian school active shooter on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>

Copy