3.7 "Reading Minority Group Poverty on Phoenix"

Explicit content warning

09/26/23 • 56 min

Join hosts Summer and Ele in another episode of the "South Phoenix Oral History Project" as they dive into the intricate world of research sources. In this episode, Summer explores a unique piece, "Minority Group Poverty on Phoenix: A Socio-Economic Survey" by Geographer Shirley J. Roberts, published in 1973. This work presents an intriguing blend of both primary and secondary source elements, sparking a fascinating discussion.
Delve into the distinction between primary and secondary sources and their significance in research. Discover how a single piece can serve dual roles, shedding light on the complexities of historical and sociological investigations. Summer and Ele unpack the nuances of utilizing such multifaceted sources to construct robust arguments.
Beyond this, the hosts provide invaluable practical advice on the art of source discovery and validation. Learn effective strategies for locating relevant material and ensuring you're on the right research path. From library databases to online resources, they guide you through the vast landscape of academic literature.
Tune in to uncover answers to crucial questions: What differentiates primary and secondary sources, and why does it matter? How can you harness the power of hybrid sources like the one discussed in this episode? What techniques and tools can you employ to ensure your research remains focused and well-supported?
Whether you're a seasoned researcher seeking to refine your source selection skills or a novice embarking on your academic journey, this episode promises to enhance your research prowess.
Music: Season 3 music is provided by Susanna Velarde Covarrubias.
Article's Reference: Roberts, Shirley J. “MINORITY-GROUP POVERTY IN PHOENIX: A Socio-Economic Survey.” The Journal of Arizona History 14, no. 4 (1973): 347–62. http://www.jstor.org/stable/41695151.

Previous Episode

3.6 "Navigating Peer-Reviewed Literature Outside Your Expertise"

In this episode of the "South Phoenix Oral History Project," hosts Summer and Ele embark on a stimulating discussion about the challenges and rewards of exploring peer-reviewed literature that falls outside one's area of expertise. Join them as they delve into the intricacies of navigating and incorporating peer-reviewed works that are crucial for strengthening arguments, even when they lie beyond the boundaries of familiarity. Explore the process of immersing oneself in unfamiliar scholarly domains, acquiring new knowledge, and effectively citing diverse perspectives.
Season 3 music is provided by Susanna Velarde Covarrubias.

Next Episode

3.8 "Reading Dealing in Toxins on the Wrong Side of the Tracks"

In Episode 8 of the "South Phoenix Oral History Project," Ele explores a thought-provoking article titled "Dealing in Toxins on the Wrong Side of the Tracks" by Diane Sicotte. This compelling piece delves into the contentious expansion of a hazardous waste facility within a marginalized neighborhood in Phoenix, offering profound insights into the unforeseen consequences of locating such facilities in vulnerable communities.
Ele dissects the article's content, summarizing the key findings and arguments. Sicotte's research unveils a troubling pattern of environmental injustice, where the siting of hazardous facilities in South Central Phoenix, a predominantly poor and minority neighborhood, has perpetuated a cycle of poverty, pollution, and drug-related crime.
Sicotte's methodology, which includes participant observation, document analysis, Census data, GIS mapping, and interviews, provides a comprehensive understanding of the complex issues at play. Residents of South Central Phoenix contend that the siting, permitting process, and subsequent expansion of the hazardous waste facility, along with the surge in drug-related crimes, are all manifestations of environmental racism.
Ele guides listeners through the critical concepts of distributive and participative injustice, shedding light on how the expansion of the facility exacerbated environmental disparities in Phoenix. The intertwining of hazardous waste and drug-related crime presents a compelling case for a holistic approach to understanding environmental justice.
But that's not all. Summer steps in to expand the discussion by exploring the geographical boundaries of South Phoenix as discussed by the author. This adds an essential layer of context to Sicotte's research, helping us comprehend the spatial dynamics of environmental injustice in this vibrant community.
Join Ele and Summer as they navigate the intricate landscape of environmental justice, offering deep insights into the complex interplay of social, economic, and geographical factors. Whether you're passionate about environmental issues, social justice, or simply curious about the real-world impact of academic research, this episode is a must-listen.
Music: Season 3 music is provided by Susanna Velarde Covarrubias.
Article's Reference: Sicotte, Diane. “Dealing in Toxins on the Wrong Side of the Tracks: Lessons from a Hazardous Waste Controversy in Phoenix.” Social Science Quarterly 89, no. 5 (2008): 1136–52. http://www.jstor.org/stable/42956367.