The Ghost of Susan Jennings: A Christmas Murder Mystery

12/04/23 • 10 min

Murder Weekly - Crime, Espionage, and Murder Thrillers

Listen in as we journey through the chilling events surrounding the mysterious death of Susan Jennings, a beloved member of the Yorkville community. We paint a vivid picture of the events leading up to her untimely death and the shocking revelation of her secret involvement with Edward Hartley, a member of the prominent Hartley family. Our discussion explores the complicated dynamics of Susan's relationships and the possible motives behind her murder, culminating in a tearful confession from her close friend Lillian. We also reflect on the impact of this tragic event on the small town of Yorkville during Christmas of 1977.
This heartbreaking mystery forever altered the fabric of this idyllic community, especially for the Hartley family. Join us as we unravel the layers of human emotions and relationships that led to this shocking crime. Hear about the somber trial that followed, the lingering memory of Susan, and the tragic fate of Edward and Elizabeth Hartley. Be prepared for a chilling exploration of jealousy, resentment, and the consequences of unrequited love.

Previous Episode

The Mystery of Rebecca Turner: A Christmas Crime

Could history be repeating itself in the quiet town of Yorkville? We're walking in the footsteps of detectives Liam Anderson and Jenna Martinez this week on Murder Weekly, as we unearth the chilling parallels between the recent murder of Rebecca Turner and an unsolved case from decades ago. In the frost-bitten woods, lies a mystery shrouded in fear and suspicion that has gripped the town once more. We're piecing together clues from the snowy crime scene, scrutinizing marks on Rebecca's body, and following a set of footprints that meanders away into the dense woods.
Venture with us into the intricate web of Rebecca's life, filled with secrets and simmering tensions. We'll scrutinize her contentious exchanges with local businessman, Mike Benson, concerning the Yorkville Christmas Festival's budget. With rumors about Mike's gambling debts and financial struggles swirling, we question his involvement in Rebecca's death. His alibi raises eyebrows and his run-ins with Rebecca cast a long, disquieting shadow. Strap in as we dissect this puzzling case and take a deep dive into the Mystery of Rebecca Turner.

Next Episode

The Lucky Ace Motel - A Christmas Murder Mystery

Ever had a Christmas adventure that turned out to be more than you bargained for? That's precisely what happened to Mike Benson, our protagonist, on his festive retreat to the Lucky Ace Motel in Atlantic City. He had intended for a quiet holiday but instead found himself tangled in a web of murder and mystery, a stark contrast to the jolly boardwalk decorations. A violent struggle in the neighboring room on Christmas Eve piqued Mike's curiosity, leading him to unearth clues involving the victim's best friend, Christopher Stevens.
We'll guide you through the twists and turns of this unexpected holiday mystery that's sure to keep you on the edge of your seat. Just when you thought this story had enough excitement, we introduce a shocking confession that changes everything. Lisa, the victim's ex-girlfriend, admits to the crime, citing self-defense against her abusive ex-boyfriend, Gary. Amidst the backdrop of twinkling lights and joyous melodies, we explore a chilling narrative of the darkness that lurks beneath the surface, even during the festive season. In the end, justice prevails, but the memories of the Lucky Ace Motel's Christmas Eve Murder continue to haunt. So, brace yourself as we take you on this thrilling journey into the heart of a holiday-themed mystery that is anything but merry and bright.