Henryetta Mass Murders: The Good Mother?: Holly Teannette Lamon McFadden
Explicit content warning
07/28/23 • 90 min
Welcome to today's case. File The Good Mom, Holly Ette Lamon McFadden,
Body of Crime Podcast Website
Link Tree
Henryetta Mass Murder Group - Follow the Facebook Henryetta Mass Murder Group to stay up to date on the latest concerning this case at
Free tickets for The Sound of Freedom
Step into the shadows of mystery and controversy on today's riveting episode. Your curiosity will be pushed to its limits as we dissect the dark enigma surrounding one of the most contentious figures in the gruesome saga of the Henrietta Mass murders journey with us into the heart of darkness, were Jesse Lee McFadden, in an alleged act of savage brutality, extinguished the lives of five children and his wife, Holly TenneT McFadden, an unspeakable carnage that culminated in his own chilling, suicide, scattering bodies across the Erie Silence.
The vast 130 acre expanse, they called home as spring blossomed. In May, it unveiled a grim Tableau, Holly. Her three children and two of their friends were found lifeless on their homestead. Catapulting Holly into the public eye as an apparent victim of Jesse's monstrous rampage. Holly, by all accounts, was the idyllic mother.
Her friendly demeanor warmed her parents and her steadfast presence. At Michael and Tiffany's track meets painted the picture of a supportive, loving parent. She shared a love of arts and crafts.
Holly and Riley kindled their creativity together. Holly wasn't just a homemaker, though. She was an entrepreneur with her sister, Heather Pettigrew. They channeled their passion into a local boutique in Henryetta called The Mystique Emporium, selling their metaphysical products, artful crafts, and all natural skincare products.
Holly to the outside world seemed to be the epitome of the good mom, right? As we peel back the veneer of normalcy, a startling narrative emerged that shook the public's perception. Eerie footage from within our home began to flood Oklahoma news channels revealing shocking scenes of drugs and drug paraphernalia, sex toys, chains, and shackles in the bedrooms, locks in the kitchens.
Suddenly, we all stared into the abyss of possible hidden truths behind their closed doors. This jarring revelation begged the haunting question, was Holly truly a good mom? Our relentless quest to unravel the convoluted case of Jesse Lee McFadden unveiled glaring oversights in his early release from incarceration.
Simultaneously, we started a meticulous dissection of Holly's enigmatic relationship with Jesse. What we unearthed painted a chilling picture, starkly contrasting the narrative offered by Holly and her grieving family. In this web of intrigue, pressing questions began to bubble up. How did Holly, a married woman from Arkansas find herself entangled with a convicted rapist and level three sex offender from McAllister, Oklahoma?
What drove her to invite such a vile entity into her life and worse into her children's lives, who clearly matched McFadden's preferred age bracket. Our quest led us to unbiasedly, scrutinize Holly's role in the dreadful events. Did she bravely battle against Jesse's horrific final act, attempting to shield her children and their friends, or did she have a darker role in the unfolding tragedy?
Unfortunately, those who hold the answers are forever silenced, leaving us a delve into the picture painted by the crime scene, and all of the evidence. We speculate, we deduce, and we question based on Holly's enigmatic narrative. Was Holly truly the good mom or was she something more sinister? Join us as we delve into these questions and more in today's gripping episode.
So Holly's story starts in 1988. She was born on February 28th. Holly Tonoutte Limon Mayo, a Pisces, to both Michael Anthony Mayo, who was 22 at the time, and Jeanette Louise Pepper, who was 24 in El Paso, Texas. At this point in time, McFadden would've been about four and a half years old.
Were they associated with the military in any kind of way back then?
Jeanette's father died in El Paso, Texas, and something tells me that that's probably where he got outta the military. I'm not positive, but he was in the military. Okay, that would be my guess. We actually have a, a photo of one of the houses that they lived in, and so if you guys end up joining us for the live, you'll get to see that.
So in 1988, in that same year, at the time that Holly was born, ...
Welcome to today's case. File The Good Mom, Holly Ette Lamon McFadden,
Body of Crime Podcast Website
Link Tree
Henryetta Mass Murder Group - Follow the Facebook Henryetta Mass Murder Group to stay up to date on the latest concerning this case at
Free tickets for The Sound of Freedom
Step into the shadows of mystery and controversy on today's riveting episode. Your curiosity will be pushed to its limits as we dissect the dark enigma surrounding one of the most contentious figures in the gruesome saga of the Henrietta Mass murders journey with us into the heart of darkness, were Jesse Lee McFadden, in an alleged act of savage brutality, extinguished the lives of five children and his wife, Holly TenneT McFadden, an unspeakable carnage that culminated in his own chilling, suicide, scattering bodies across the Erie Silence.
The vast 130 acre expanse, they called home as spring blossomed. In May, it unveiled a grim Tableau, Holly. Her three children and two of their friends were found lifeless on their homestead. Catapulting Holly into the public eye as an apparent victim of Jesse's monstrous rampage. Holly, by all accounts, was the idyllic mother.
Her friendly demeanor warmed her parents and her steadfast presence. At Michael and Tiffany's track meets painted the picture of a supportive, loving parent. She shared a love of arts and crafts.
Holly and Riley kindled their creativity together. Holly wasn't just a homemaker, though. She was an entrepreneur with her sister, Heather Pettigrew. They channeled their passion into a local boutique in Henryetta called The Mystique Emporium, selling their metaphysical products, artful crafts, and all natural skincare products.
Holly to the outside world seemed to be the epitome of the good mom, right? As we peel back the veneer of normalcy, a startling narrative emerged that shook the public's perception. Eerie footage from within our home began to flood Oklahoma news channels revealing shocking scenes of drugs and drug paraphernalia, sex toys, chains, and shackles in the bedrooms, locks in the kitchens.
Suddenly, we all stared into the abyss of possible hidden truths behind their closed doors. This jarring revelation begged the haunting question, was Holly truly a good mom? Our relentless quest to unravel the convoluted case of Jesse Lee McFadden unveiled glaring oversights in his early release from incarceration.
Simultaneously, we started a meticulous dissection of Holly's enigmatic relationship with Jesse. What we unearthed painted a chilling picture, starkly contrasting the narrative offered by Holly and her grieving family. In this web of intrigue, pressing questions began to bubble up. How did Holly, a married woman from Arkansas find herself entangled with a convicted rapist and level three sex offender from McAllister, Oklahoma?
What drove her to invite such a vile entity into her life and worse into her children's lives, who clearly matched McFadden's preferred age bracket. Our quest led us to unbiasedly, scrutinize Holly's role in the dreadful events. Did she bravely battle against Jesse's horrific final act, attempting to shield her children and their friends, or did she have a darker role in the unfolding tragedy?
Unfortunately, those who hold the answers are forever silenced, leaving us a delve into the picture painted by the crime scene, and all of the evidence. We speculate, we deduce, and we question based on Holly's enigmatic narrative. Was Holly truly the good mom or was she something more sinister? Join us as we delve into these questions and more in today's gripping episode.
So Holly's story starts in 1988. She was born on February 28th. Holly Tonoutte Limon Mayo, a Pisces, to both Michael Anthony Mayo, who was 22 at the time, and Jeanette Louise Pepper, who was 24 in El Paso, Texas. At this point in time, McFadden would've been about four and a half years old.
Were they associated with the military in any kind of way back then?
Jeanette's father died in El Paso, Texas, and something tells me that that's probably where he got outta the military. I'm not positive, but he was in the military. Okay, that would be my guess. We actually have a, a photo of one of the houses that they lived in, and so if you guys end up joining us for the live, you'll get to see that.
So in 1988, in that same year, at the time that Holly was born, ...
Previous Episode
Henryetta Mass Murders: Monster - Jesse Lee McFadden
Welcome to today's case, file Monster, Jesse Lee McFadden
Body of Crime Podcast Website
Link Tree
Henryetta Mass Murder Group - Follow the Facebook Henryetta Mass Murder Group to stay up to date on the latest concerning this case at
Free tickets for The Sound of Freedom
As we delve into the dark depths of this horrifying case of the Henrietta Mass murders. Our focus is on the true monster, a man whose name send shivers down the spines of those who know his heinous deeds. Jesse Lee McFadden. Our story unfolds in the heart of an American city, steeped in history where tells of cowboys and pioneers resonate throughout the streets.
But beneath the nostalgic facade lies a sinister presence that emerges from the shadows. Welcome to Henrietta, a small town nestled in Ogee County, Oklahoma, with a population just over 5,600. This state, often referred to as the Bible Belt, is unfortunately notorious for being one of the largest strongholds of the Ku Klux Klan, or K K K.
Oklahoma ranked a dismal 43rd out of the 50 states in terms of livability. Paints a troubling picture with statistics such as 48th and healthcare and education, a disheartening tie for first place in unemployment, and a concerning 43rd in crime and corrections. Despite ranking fourth in incarceration rates, it holds distressing titles of a ninth in rape and 12th in violent crime.
Moreover, allegations of corruption plague both the city and county as Oklahoma was recently ranked as the 11th most corrupt state. It seems that this tumultuous environment provides a fertile breeding ground for the likes of Jesse Lee McFadden. Prepare yourselves as we journey into the twisted psyche of our central figure.
McFadden is not only a murderer, but also a registered sex offender and rapist. Despite a laundry list of red flags and his behavior encounters with law enforcement and entanglements with the legal system, the state of Oklahoma and the Oklahoma Department of Corrections allowed him to step out of the prison walls, instilling in him a sense of untouchability and even empowerment.
Unsurprisingly, McFadden's behavior remained unchanged, if not more insidious, even during his time behind bars. And then a shocking turn of events, a murder suicide that claimed the lives of five innocent children. As the state deflects blame, citing the lack of support and an overburdened justice system, a dark cloud of corruption hovers over the investigation, leaving the survivors and victims families to shoulder the responsibilities that should rightfully belong to state officials, law enforcement, and legislators.
Join us as we deep dive the chilling details of this homegrown Oklahoma monster, Jesse Lee McFadden.
As we continue our dissent into the depths of this chilling narrative, we now shift our focus to the life of the monster himself. Jesse Lee McFadden, born into a world cloaked in secrecy and shadows, Jesse emerged under the stage of Wichita, Kansas. A city whose foundation rested on the remnants of a Native American village, a tapestry woven with trade and promise.
It was on that fateful day, August 24th, 1983, that a Virgo came into existence. Did, did the world know of the sinister destiny that lay in wait for this troubled soul raised by his young mother, LaDonna Jean McFadden? In the absence of a father figure whose identity remained shrouded in mystery, Jesse's path would become entangled with dark recesses of human nature.
A legacy was set in motion, one that would forever haunt the annals of true crime history. As we delve deeper into the intricate web of the McFadden family, we uncovered their journey from Wichita, Kansas to McAllister Oklahoma, a town steep in the ancestral heritage of the McFadden lineage, nestled within the boundaries of Pittsburgh County.
It was here at 90 41 Redbird Drive and LaDonna sought a sense of permanence, a place to call home. However, this dwelling often deemed unsuitable or raising of family would become the backdrop of McFadden's upbringing, shaping the course of his and his brother's. Cody McFadden's lives you will learn about McFadden, a true monster that haunted the lives of many.
We'll explore the chilling psychology behind his crimes and unravel the intricate web of forensic connections that built his criminal profile. We'll delve into the disturbing motivations behind sexual assault and murder, examining the patterns of behavior that define a monster....
Next Episode
Unseen Battles: The Plight of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women in the USA
Welcome to today's case, file Unseen Battle, the plight of missing and murdered indigenous women in the U S A
Body of Crime Podcast Website
Link Tree
MMIWUSA PayPal Donations
Free tickets for The Sound of Freedom
Violence such as murder, rape, and other violent crime against Native Americans and Alaska and natives far exceed the national averages. For decades, native American and Alaska native communities have struggled with high rates of assault, abduction, and murder of women. Community advocates describe the crisis as a legacy of generations of government, policies of forced removal, land, seizures, and violence inflicted on native peoples.
A study conducted by the National Institute of Justice found 84.3% of American Indian and Alaska native women have experienced violence in their lifetime, and of those 56.1%. Have experienced sexual violence overall, more than 1.5 million. American Indian and Alaska native women have experienced violence in their lifetime.
When looking at missing and murdered cases, data shows that Native American and Alaska native women make up a significant portion of missing and murdered individuals according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. C D C, national Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey. American Indian and Alaska native women experienced the second highest rate of homicide in 2020.
American Indian and Alaska native men had the second highest rate of homicide compared with males and other racial and ethnic groups. Homicide was in the top 10 leading causes of death of American Indian and Alaska Native women ages one to 45, and American Indian and Alaska Native men ages one to 54.
One in seven American Indian and Alaskan native men were forced to penetrate someone during their lifetime. As human trafficking has become a world crisis, the Government Accountability Office released a report titled Human Trafficking. Investigations in Indian country or involving Native Americans and actions needed to better report on victims served g a o surveyed, tribal and major city law enforcement agencies and victim service providers on human trafficking investigations.
Victim services and barriers to identifying and serving native victims. Many identified lack of training on identifying and responding appropriately to victims, victim shame and reluctance to come forward, and lack of service provider resources as barriers to investigating cases and serving victims.
According to the National Crime Information Center in 2016, there were 5,712 reports of missing American Indian and Alaska Native women and girls through the US Department of Justices, federal Missing Persons Database, but the National Information Clearing House and Resource Center for missing, unidentified and unclaimed persons cases across the United States called the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System.
NamUs. Only logged 116 of those cases highlighting an alarming gap. The Bureau of Indian Affairs estimates that there are approximately 4,200 missing and murdered cases that have gone unsolved. The largest gap identified has been investigative resources, a non-profit organization called the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, u S A.
★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★If you like this episode you’ll love
Episode Comments
Generate a badge
Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode
<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/body-of-crime-256222/henryetta-mass-murders-the-good-mother-holly-teannette-lamon-mcfadden-31958671"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to henryetta mass murders: the good mother?: holly teannette lamon mcfadden on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>
Copy