
When Baseball Was Still Topps - Phil Coffin
01/27/25 • 44 min
Baseball history through the lens of the 1959 Topps Baseball Card collection.
Phil Coffin, looks back at 1959 through the history of the complete 1959 baseball card collection. He revisits baseball players, managers & stories with short entertaining essays
Back in the Day
- Phil Coffin, Author & New York Times Editor
- Mark & Phil reflect on their early days at The Courier-Journal
- Phil’s journey from Louisville to The New York Times (1997)
When Baseball Was Still Topps
- One of the best baseball books of 2024 by Sports Collectors Digest
- Short Essays on each of the 1959 Topps baseball card set
- Growing up in Indianapolis as a baseball fan
- Watching 1959 World Series between the Dodgers & White Sox with his brothers
Baseball History
- Comparing reports of Mickey Mantle & Derek Jeter as young prospects
- Ted (Klu) Kruszewski, Al Lopez, & Sparky Anderson
- Beyond the stats
The 1959 Chicago White Sox
- Tampa Baseball Museum & Al Lopez
- White Sox integrating baseball, Larry Doby, Minnie Miñoso, & Al Smith
- Al Smith beer drenching of 1959 World Series
- Ted (Klu) Kluszewski’s sleeveless
- Harmon Killebrew
- Overlap of Negro Leagues and Major League Baseball history & Hank Aaron's journey from the Indianapolis Clowns to MLB
Building a collection
- Started with 6-card wax packs for a nickel with gum
- The elusive Milt Graff
- Childhood collection tossed out by mom
- Path to rebuild the collection
- In “Jersey” you got to know, a guy to get Mickey Mantle
- Bob Gibson rookie card
Inside When Baseball Was Still Topps
- Essays on all 572 cards from the 1959 Topps set,
- Ted Williams MIA in Topps collection due to exclusive contract with Fleer
- Hall of Famer Bob Gibson’s Rookie card, one of the most valuable in the set
- Maury Wills, debuted in 1959 but was left out of the set due to doubts about his potential
Baseball’s History and Evolution:
- Stories of baseball legends like Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth, and Ted Williams
- The evolution of baseball cards, from Topps’ dominance in the 1950s to today’s competitive memorabilia market
- Eddie Gaedel’s one-game fame
- Endurance of catchers
- Challenges of following modern baseball with expanded rosters and teams compared to the 16-team era of 1959
- Baseball fans connect with the game through history, stories, & tangible memorabilia
Phil’s Upcoming Book:
- A Baseball Book of Days: 31 Moments That Transformed the Game, explores pivotal dates in baseball history
- Stories include Babe Ruth’s sale to the Yankees, Jackie Robinson’s first game, and the dominance of Dominican players in MLB
Where to Find Phil Coffin’s Books:
- When Baseball Was Still Topps: Available at McFarlandBooks com and on Amazon
- A Baseball Book of Days: Pre-order now for its upcoming release (just in time for spring training)
Mark is on Blue Sky at @baseballbizondeck.bsky.social BaseballBiz On Deck is on iheart, apple, spotify, amazon music & at www.baseballbizondeck.com
Special Thanks to X-Take-R-U-X for the music Rocking Forward
Baseball history through the lens of the 1959 Topps Baseball Card collection.
Phil Coffin, looks back at 1959 through the history of the complete 1959 baseball card collection. He revisits baseball players, managers & stories with short entertaining essays
Back in the Day
- Phil Coffin, Author & New York Times Editor
- Mark & Phil reflect on their early days at The Courier-Journal
- Phil’s journey from Louisville to The New York Times (1997)
When Baseball Was Still Topps
- One of the best baseball books of 2024 by Sports Collectors Digest
- Short Essays on each of the 1959 Topps baseball card set
- Growing up in Indianapolis as a baseball fan
- Watching 1959 World Series between the Dodgers & White Sox with his brothers
Baseball History
- Comparing reports of Mickey Mantle & Derek Jeter as young prospects
- Ted (Klu) Kruszewski, Al Lopez, & Sparky Anderson
- Beyond the stats
The 1959 Chicago White Sox
- Tampa Baseball Museum & Al Lopez
- White Sox integrating baseball, Larry Doby, Minnie Miñoso, & Al Smith
- Al Smith beer drenching of 1959 World Series
- Ted (Klu) Kluszewski’s sleeveless
- Harmon Killebrew
- Overlap of Negro Leagues and Major League Baseball history & Hank Aaron's journey from the Indianapolis Clowns to MLB
Building a collection
- Started with 6-card wax packs for a nickel with gum
- The elusive Milt Graff
- Childhood collection tossed out by mom
- Path to rebuild the collection
- In “Jersey” you got to know, a guy to get Mickey Mantle
- Bob Gibson rookie card
Inside When Baseball Was Still Topps
- Essays on all 572 cards from the 1959 Topps set,
- Ted Williams MIA in Topps collection due to exclusive contract with Fleer
- Hall of Famer Bob Gibson’s Rookie card, one of the most valuable in the set
- Maury Wills, debuted in 1959 but was left out of the set due to doubts about his potential
Baseball’s History and Evolution:
- Stories of baseball legends like Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth, and Ted Williams
- The evolution of baseball cards, from Topps’ dominance in the 1950s to today’s competitive memorabilia market
- Eddie Gaedel’s one-game fame
- Endurance of catchers
- Challenges of following modern baseball with expanded rosters and teams compared to the 16-team era of 1959
- Baseball fans connect with the game through history, stories, & tangible memorabilia
Phil’s Upcoming Book:
- A Baseball Book of Days: 31 Moments That Transformed the Game, explores pivotal dates in baseball history
- Stories include Babe Ruth’s sale to the Yankees, Jackie Robinson’s first game, and the dominance of Dominican players in MLB
Where to Find Phil Coffin’s Books:
- When Baseball Was Still Topps: Available at McFarlandBooks com and on Amazon
- A Baseball Book of Days: Pre-order now for its upcoming release (just in time for spring training)
Mark is on Blue Sky at @baseballbizondeck.bsky.social BaseballBiz On Deck is on iheart, apple, spotify, amazon music & at www.baseballbizondeck.com
Special Thanks to X-Take-R-U-X for the music Rocking Forward
Previous Episode

MLB beyond the Dodgers + Bring Pete Alonso back to Tampa Bay
- Executive Order – One Baseball – All-Americans
- Can the Rays bring Pete Alonso home
- Alonso would be a strong leader on the team & marketing asset for the Rays
- Past considerations with Freddie Freeman & Nelson Cruz
- The Return of Ozzie Timmons
- Competitive Balance between MLB teams
- Salary Caps & Floors
- Dodgers & the NL West Superteams
- Roki Sasaki signs with the Dodgers & International Signings
- New College, new donor, new ballfield, foul ball onto the Sarasota airfield
- CBA – Baseball Collective Bargaining Agreement with players & owners
- Frustration with elite teams spending like Dodgers & Mets
- Looking forward to a very strong Junior Caminero to take the field for the Rays
- Christopher Morel’s elite bat speed, placing him among top players like Aaron Judge, Shohei Ohtani, and Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
- Evan Longoria – lets sign him up as a coach for the Rays
- Visa concerns for International players
Follow Mat on Blue Sky at https://bsky.app/profile/matgermain.bsky.social
You can find Mark on Blue Sky at https://bsky.app/profile/baseballbizondeck.bsky.social
Special thanks to XTaKeRuX for the music “Rocking Forward
Next Episode

Lou Schiff - Attorneys in the Hall of Fame, Tony La Russa, fans in Japan & Marlins
Author & Judge Lou Schiff joins Mat & Mark
28 years on the bench
Mitchell Hamline School of Law
Upcoming book: Attorneys in the Baseball Hall of Fame
Plans for Marlins games in LA and Milwaukee
Visits to Japan and LA
World Baseball Classic
Caribbean baseball fans & attendance comparison with the Marlins
Past Marlins stars (Yelich, Ozuna, Stanton, Realmuto) & team-building challenges
Ownership lack of long-term commitment affecting fan engagement
The importance of consistency in building a franchise
Pitching depth concerns f(Yuri Pérez’s return, Sandy Alcantara’s status)
Junior Caminero’s dramatic home run
Building a Competitive Team – The importance of a strong general manager and financial strategy. Discussion on past Marlins trades and franchise decisions.
Reflections on Derek Jeter, Kim Ng, and Don Mattingly's tenure. Why Kim Ng was the best thing to happen to the Marlins and the controversy surrounding her departure.
MLB’s Financial Landscape – impact of ownership decisions on team success, the need for a salary floor, and the debate over trade equity.
Should MLB Penalize Team Owners when their teams lose?
Ownership Models in Baseball – Comparing private vs. public ownership, with examples like the Atlanta Braves and the Green Bay Packers
Dodgers, Contracts, and MLB’s Future – Examining deferred contracts like Shohei Ohtani’s and how they might push MLB toward a salary cap & floor.
Rule Changes Under Rob Manfred – The pros and cons of pitch clocks, bigger bases, and the controversial "Manfred Man" in extra innings.
The Fan Experience in Japan vs. the U.S. –
World Series Predictions & Hopes
Mat Germain predicts the Red Sox could be the next World Series winner.
Hopes for early elimination of the Dodger
Would love to see the Pirates or Brewers in the World Series.
Proposed Rule Changes in Baseball
Lou Schiff wants to eliminate the (DH) and bring back pitcher batting, bunting, and small ball.
Modern baseball has too many strikeouts and misses the era of stolen bases and more strategic play.
Mat Germain argues keeping the DH is an equalizer for small-market teams, allowing them to bring in veteran hitters like Nelson Cruz to compete with wealthier teams.
Automated Umpiring & Replay System Changes
Automated strike zones are gaining traction, with MLB experimenting by measuring players’ strike zones individually
Believes bias could affect decisions, even unintentionally, due to relationships or experience levels.
Suggests an approach, where calls are reviewed without prior knowledge of the on-field ruling.
How does bias influences umpiring decisions
Attorneys in the Baseball Hall of Fame" is Co-authored by Lou Schiff & 10 other contributors, covering 11 Hall of Fame members who were also lawyers.
The book Includes players, owners, commissioners, & managers with legal backgrounds.
Lou wrote the chapter on Tony La Russa, the only living attorney in the Baseball Hall of Fame.
La Russa’s signed as a "bonus baby" with Kansas City but later pursued law later
Attended law school and passed the bar exam but never actively practiced law.
Lou interviewed several people connected to La Russa, including:
Prof. Charles Earhart (his law professor), Scott Tozian (law school friend), Judge Robin Fuson (former player under La Russa), Mike Veeck (his first managerial job connection), Bill Dooley (his former boss)
Appendix includes statistics on Hall of Fame lawyers: Net worth, marriages, law schools, and more
Follow Mat on Blue Sky at https://bsky.app/profile/matgermain.bsky.social
You can find Mark on Blue Sky at https://bsky.app/profile/baseballbizondeck.bsky.social
BaseballBiz On Deck - When Baseball Was Still Topps - Phil Coffin
Transcript
Phil Coffin - When Baseball Was Still Topps
[00:00:00] Mark Corbett: Welcome to BaseballBiz On Deck. I am Mark Corbett, your host. And with me today, I have Mr. Phil Coffin. This guy's fantastic. Knew Phil back in the day. How long is back in the day? Is it, is that a real measurement Phil?
[00:00:13] Phil Coffin: It's been a while. We each had less gray hair then.
[00:00:18] Mark Corbett: Oh gosh, tell me about her brother
If you like this episode you’ll love
Episode Comments
Generate a badge
Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode
<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/baseballbiz-on-deck-233808/when-baseball-was-still-topps-phil-coffin-83019971"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to when baseball was still topps - phil coffin on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>
Copy