Asian Provocation

I speak with Robert K. Beshara روبرت بشارة, Ph.D., a scholar, psychoanalyst, musician, actor, director and artist; he has authored Decolonial Psychoanalysis: Towards Critical Islamophobia Studies (Routledge, 2019), Freud & Said (2021), but I discovered his work through his book, A Psychoanalytic Biography of Ye (2023).

In this conversation, Robert speaks through a psychoanalytically informed lens about Ye, or the artist formally known as Kanye West, Fascism as False Being, the Legacy of Unconditional Love, Black Male Studies, and much more.

Additionally, from the episode, you may find interest in some further reading:

Through the Zone of Nonbeing: A Reading of Black Skin, White Masks in Celebration of Fanon’s Eightieth Birthday — LEWIS R. GORDON

The Man-Not: Race, Class, Genre, and the Dilemmas of Black Manhood — Tommy J. Curry

Can't Get You Out of My Head - Part 1: Bloodshed on Wolf Mountain — Adam Curtis

A news headline reposted gained much response, “Woman slams selfish paragliders who 'made her think Hamas was invading Doncaster’—A woman panicked her village near Doncaster was under attack when she spotted a number of paragliders flying over her home and thought they were from Hamas.”

The photo: a group of paragliders above the green rolling hills. It disturbed me to think of this woman in Doncaster. But what was even more disturbing was my ability to empathize with her sentiment.

My family and I emigrated to Australia in 1992. We were encouraged to assimilate. In that process, one does not only learn the language but also the cultural norms (one brings an Esky, short for the derogatory exonym, Eskimo, to the beach with beers, and not hotpot), fears (tall poppy syndrome and being perceived as Un-Australian), and anxieties (the Chinks are invading and taking over the country).

When we arrived, I knew only one word in the English language: Apple. Through neocolonialism, however, I was taught the English alphabet. I made friends pretty quickly. My mother would encourage me to socialize with the whites and integrate. I was to be 大方, be generous with a sense of magnanimity, open-hearted and open-minded, Großzugigkeit or Offenheit.

I was fond of the first few months in Australia. We had escaped the industrialization of Taiwan, a Faustian pact with the devil (United States of America), by becoming the new factory slave of the world. In a matter of a decade, some would call it a rags-to-riches story, but at the cost of environmental destruction. But I was seven years old, and all I know is that no teacher or parent in Australia was legally allowed to punish me physically. No more beatings. No more canning. It felt like dying and going to heaven. The air was clean, and we’d spot kangaroos and koalas outside our house.

Our school held its annual fete that spring. I participated in the first sports event, a 50-meter dash. I was so excited because I was the first to cross the finish line, but when the award came, they gave first prize to Brenton, the white boy who finished behind me. I didn’t have the words yet to speak up. Dad consoled me and reminded me to be 大方. We walked by a stand where they were recruiting kids for the local Cub Scouts. Dad signed me up that day, and I started to attend on Tuesday nights.

I was the only one non-White kid in the scouts. I got a uniform and learned the scout salute. We raised the Australian flag and learned bushcraft. We ate vegemite sandwiches and swapped Australian bush stories. I became good friends with Andrew and Nigel because they were also in my class at school. Was I integrating? I didn’t know that word yet at the time. But I knew how to respond when Andrew would say to me with a smile, “See you at Scouts tonight?”

Yep, you bet, I’d say in return.

Not only did we go to the same school and attend Scouts on Tuesday evenings, but we’d also go camping on the weekends. I learned to kayak, start fires, and eat cornflakes with sugar and milk for breakfast. Badges accumulated on my sleeve as I sewed them on myself over time.

One day, Andrew invited me to ride over to his place after school with Nigel, which turned out to be only a few blocks away. We’d ride our bikes in circles and play street cricket until his parents called him in for tea. I remember the mustache of his father and his mum standing by the screen door. What does racism look like? The next day, I saw Andrew at the water fountain and initiated this time, See you at Scouts tonight?

Andrew looked at me with a new face and emotion I didn’t recognize. Perhaps now I could categorize him as expressing a state of psychological distress, distrust, suspicion, or fear. But I remember understanding what he said, “We’ve been invaded by the Chinese!”

Over the next few years, I would experience being sneered at by kids at school as a “Qing Chong Chinaman” which was strange because my grandfather was at war with China. I was even born on the infamous 八二三砲戰 (August 23 Artillery Battle), which made him very proud, as he saw it as an auspicious sign. My ancestor, Koxinga, fought against the Qing dynasty and saw them as the mortal enemies of the great Ming dynasty. And here I was, being sneered at as a Qing Chong Chinaman? I wanted to correct the kid and explain, but how? Just as I couldn’t say to the teacher, no, I was first, I was again unable to explain the absurdity to myself or the bullies.

It would take me another few decades to understand that none of this mattered, for reason and logic is not what can remedy the neurosis of racism. One cannot sim...

Edward Said’s daughter Najla directed the above rules at the blatant misinformation from mainstream news outlets. Someone wrote in response:

So I figured today, Monday December 11, 2023, as part of the global #strikeforgaza we are asked to:

Don’t buy anything, cash or online.

Don’t use your bank account, and don’t make any transaction

Don’t leave your house

Don’t use your social media for anything other than Palestine awareness

Use hashtag #strikeforgaza

So, to help each other out, I’m providing the answers and information to Najla’s questions to the so-called experts. Hopefully, this helps the collective to have a better critical understanding of the fight against propaganda.

1. Define Zionism

It is a nationalist and political movement that supports the settler colonialist nation-state in what was Palestine, with a Western-backed regime called Israel.

Zion is a hill in Jerusalem that is symbolic of Jewish religious scripture and history.

Orthodox Judaism, which is known as Haredi Judaism, particularly within certain Hasidic groups like Satmar Hasidism, has the interpretation of the Talmud and various rabbinical writings that the Jewish people were exiled from the land of Israel by divine decree and are prohibited from returning until the prophesied return of the Messiah, an event that has not yet occurred. As such, it is considered blasphemous for individuals to assert their right to return, as this may be perceived as religious propaganda concealing underlying geopolitical motives.

One of the primary sources for this view is the writings of Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum, the founder of the Satmar Hasidic dynasty. In his book "VaYoel Moshe," Rabbi Teitelbaum argues that establishing a Jewish state before the arrival of the Messiah is forbidden according to Jewish law. He bases his argument on three oaths mentioned in the Talmud, Tractate Ketubot 111a. These oaths are interpreted as 1) The Jewish people should not ascend to Eretz Israel (the Land of Israel) as a wall (i.e., en masse and forcefully), 2) The Jewish people should not rebel against the nations, and 3) The nations should not oppress Israel excessively.

Zionism gained momentum under the leadership of Theodor Herzl, an Austro-Hungarian journalist and writer. Herzl wrote in 1896 the book Der Judenstaat, the Jewish State, as a solution to the Jewish question of European antisemitism, which advocates for Jewish emigration to Palestine (the book was published in Leipzig and Vienna and was originally titled “Address to the Rothschild” referring to the Rothschild family banking dynasty, as Herzl planned to deliver it as a speech to the Rothschild family. Baron Edmond de Rothschild rejected Herzl’s plan, feeling that it threatened Jews in the Diaspora).

What started out as an emigration project, however, transformed into a colonialization project turned genocide, as they passed on the same antisemitism that pushed the Jews out of Europe in the first place.

Zionism encompasses various ideologies but was pushed forward by the British Mandate of Palestine. Britain defeated the Ottoman Empire, and the territories in the Middle East, including Palestine, were divided among the Allied powers.

In 1917, the British government issued the Balfour Declaration, expressing support for establishing a “National Home for the Jewish People” in Palestine, which was then an Ottoman region with a majority Arab population that can be traced back to the 7th century CE with the Arab Conquest following the death of the Prophet Muhammad in 632 CE, followed by the Ottoman Era, 1517-1917 CE. After World War I, the League of Nations formally granted Britain the mandate over Palestine in 1920, which was confirmed in 1922. The League of Nations was heavily influenced by colonial powers and their interests, with many of the member states' European powers having significant colonial holdings. The League's mandate system, which was intended to administer former German and Ottoman territ...