Wicked Wanderings

GET YOUR WICKED WANDERINGS PODCAST MERCH NOW

Thirty years have passed since the Chuck E. Cheese tragedy in Aurora, Colorado, and yet the wounds remain as deep and painful as ever. Jess's sister Heather joins us to share her intimate connection to that fateful night on December 14, 1993, when Nathan Dunlap's quest for vengeance claimed the lives of four innocent people, including her friend. Together, we traverse the haunting memories, the loss felt by the community, and the haunting aftermath that forever altered the lives of those who survived.
With Heather's unique insights, we peel back the layers of Dunlap's psyche, attempting to understand the role his troubled history played in leading up to the massacre. Deliberating on his erratic behavior, the trial that followed, and his death penalty case, we engage in a profound discussion on the intersections of mental health, criminal justice, and the ultimate question of whether such a violent act can be attributed solely to illness or if there were other contributing factors. This episode shines a light on the complexities of a person's background and the long, difficult road of the legal processes that unfold in the wake of such crimes.
As we conclude the episode, our focus shifts to the delicate subjects of loss and the possibility of forgiveness. Remembering Sylvia through her own words on forgiveness, we honor the lives that were stolen and explore the emotional journey of those who have been left to pick up the pieces. Join us as we offer a tribute to the indomitable human spirit and the power of a community united in grief and resilience. This is more than just a story of a crime; it's a testament to the lives it has touched and the ongoing struggle to find peace and closure.
Death Row Stories

If you'd like to show your support for Wicked Wanderings and join our community of dedicated listeners, you can start contributing for as little as $3 a month. Your support helps us continue to explore the darkest and most intriguing mysteries, bringing you captivating stories from the world of true crime and the unexplained. Click the link to become a valued member of our podcast family.
Don't forget to rate, review, and follow us on your favorite streaming platform.
Wicked Wanderings Website
Linktree
Instagram
Hannah's Bookstagram
We'd love to hear from you!
Email us @ [email protected]
Text Us @ CLICK HERE
Wicked Wanderings is hosted by Hannah Fitzpatrick & Courtney Keating and is produced by Rob Fitzpatrick. Music by Sascha Ende. Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 Lic.
Wicked Wanderings is a Production of Studio 113

1 Listener

🔒 Bonus Ep. 5: Am I An Ass Hole

Wicked Wanderings

07/08/24 • 16 min

Subscriber-only episode

Can naming a baby spark a family feud? Join us on this episode of Wicked Wanderings, where personal boundaries and family dynamics take center stage. First, we dive into the emotional turmoil of whether to invite an estranged father, who has struggled with addiction, to a wedding. With raw honesty, Jess and Hannah navigate the murky waters of prioritizing personal feelings versus family obligations, providing thoughtful insights into setting boundaries. Next, we tackle the controversy of a sister-in-law choosing a name for her newborn that is already held by a niece, stirring up deep family tensions. Jess and Hannah dig into the emotional layers of name ownership, shared names, and the importance of gut feelings in making such poignant decisions.
In our Sibling Wedding Dilemma chapter, we explore the sensitive dynamics of naming within families. Is it okay to have multiple Jennifers, or should families steer away from common names? We then switch gears to discuss a 23-year-old brother's decision to let his nine-year-old sister sleep in his bed after a nightmare. Jess and Hannah weigh in on the mother's concerns and the sibling's perspective, offering a balanced view on the subject. Finally, we wrap up with heartfelt gratitude to our loyal listeners, encouraging everyone to stay curious and keep wandering. Don't miss out on this emotional rollercoaster—make sure to follow us on social media and check out our exclusive merch for some Wicked Cozy apparel!

1 Listener

Ep. 12 - Behind the Mic - Meet Your Hosts, Hannah and Jess

Wicked Wanderings

11/22/23 • 49 min

GET YOUR WICKED WANDERINGS PODCAST MERCH NOW

Join us for an intimate session on Wicked Wanderings as Rob, the producer, delves into a variety of questions to help you get to know our hosts, Hannah and Jess, a little bit better.
Rob asks a series of intriguing questions, unraveling the backgrounds and personalities of Hannah and Jess. From their formative years and sources of inspiration to their defining moments and passions beyond their roles on the show, this episode peels back the layers to reveal the lives and interests that shape these captivating hosts.
Tune in as they discuss their childhoods, sources of inspiration, defining moments, hobbies, favorite books, movies, and music, as well as the people who have influenced their lives. They share personal challenges, lessons learned, and their future goals and aspirations.
Get ready for an engaging and personal conversation that goes beyond the mysteries they explore on Wicked Wanderings. Subscribe now to uncover the unique perspectives and personalities of Hannah and Jess in this special episode.

1 Listener

Ep. 39: Social Media Questions and Listener's Answer's

Wicked Wanderings

05/29/24 • 24 min

Ready for some spine-tingling tales and lively debates? Celebrate Jess's graduation with us as we share some hearty laughs about our educational escapades and special skills. Then, get ready for chills as we explore ghost stories submitted by our listeners, kicking off with listener's eerie tale of disappearing water. Ever wondered if there's a supernatural explanation for everyday mysteries? Join the discussion as we debate iconic horror movie villains with insights from you, the listener. Who reigns supreme in the realm of scares—Jason, Freddy, or Michael Myers? Expect a spirited chat on our personal horror favorites that’ll leave you questioning your next movie night choice.
Hold on tight as we navigate the murky waters of true crime and the paranormal. We delve into the dark world of Luka Magnotta, the chilling cat killer whose heinous acts were unraveled by internet sleuths, and the infamous Ken and Barbie killers, Paul Bernardo, and Karla Homolka. Haunted locations like the Stanley Hotel and the eerie Island of Dead Dolls will make you reconsider your next vacation spot. We cap it all off with a real-life ghostly encounter involving a child's scream and a missing light switch, promising goosebumps and sleepless nights. Don't miss this episode packed with unsettling stories and vibrant discussions!

1 Listener

Ep. 36: The Duct Tape Killer: Dissecting the Dreadful Saga of Robert Leroy Anderson's Reign of Terror

Wicked Wanderings

05/08/24 • 60 min

Join us for a gripping journey through the nefarious acts of Robert Leroy Anderson, the Duct Tape Killer, as we piece together the heart-rending stories of Piper Streyle and Larissa Demanski. Venture into the chilling details of their abductions in South Dakota and explore the unsettling reality of a killer's meticulous methods. With the insightful contributions of our guest, Kaylyn, we strike a balance, intertwining the grave nature of the case with the lighter side of our podcasting adventures, personal anecdotes, and the peculiarities of online dating.
As we scrutinize Anderson's criminal escapades, the conversation takes an unexpected turn, traversing through the significance of observant neighbors to the oddities of criminal behavior. Witness how a simple mistake at a Bible camp began the unraveling of Anderson's facade of ignorance, how family dynamics play into the narratives we discuss, and how our own lives intersect in surprising ways with those we'd never expect to connect with.
The episode culminates with the dramatic trial and conviction of Anderson, where we ponder the complexities of justice and the impact of his crimes on the families left behind. From the evidence that sealed his fate to the emotional aftermath for those involved, Kaylyn helps us navigate the turbulent emotions of a case that, despite reaching a legal conclusion, leaves haunting questions unanswered. This episode promises more than just a true crime story—it's an exploration of human nature, justice, and the indelible mark left on a community by one man's dark legacy.

1 Listener

🔒 Bonus Ep. 6: Am I An Ass Hole

Wicked Wanderings

08/17/24 • 15 min

Subscriber-only episode

What happens when your boyfriend's ex shows up at a wedding with unexpected news? Join Hannah and Courtney in this riveting bonus episode of Wicked Wanderings as they dissect a jaw-dropping "Am I the Asshole?" scenario. Discover the rollercoaster of emotions one woman experiences after being excluded from a wedding, uncovering her boyfriend's intentions to cheat, and her bold decision to reclaim her power with a sun-soaked beach getaway. The plot thickens as surprising revelations about the ex’s pregnancy and marriage come to light, culminating in a satisfying breakup that leaves no stone unturned.
In another explosive segment, the duo tackles the fallout from a party confrontation where a friend's personal history is laid bare. Spark intense debates about privacy, trust, and societal double standards as Hannah and Courtney navigate the murky waters of past relationships and the immature focus on body counts. Wrapping up with heartfelt thanks to their dedicated listeners and a nod to their stellar production team, this episode is a rollercoaster of emotions and insights you won't want to miss. Plus, don’t forget to check out the latest merch and follow Wicked Wanderings on social media for more exclusive content!

Ep. 45: From Ghostly Whispers to Revolutionary Horror: The Tale of Two Tragedies

Wicked Wanderings

07/10/24 • 26 min

What happens when a ghost from 1673 appears to solve her own murder? Join us as we uncover the eerie tale of Rebecca Cornell, whose spirit allegedly revealed the grim details of her death to her brother. We'll set the stage with a playful debate on classic Chevy Chase and Steve Martin films, lightheartedly exposing Hannah's surprising lack of familiarity with "Christmas Vacation" and "Three Amigos." But the mood shifts dramatically as we traverse the dark corridors of history to explore the tragic hardships Rebecca faced and the disturbing events that followed her spectral visit.
Our journey through history continues with a chilling account of William Beadle, a Connecticut merchant whose life unraveled during the Revolutionary War, leading to the merciless slaughter of his entire family. We'll delve into Beadle's background, his twisted rationale, and the horrifying aftermath of his actions, including the townspeople's disturbing response. As we wrap up, we express our heartfelt gratitude to our loyal Wicked Wanderings community and invite you to stay curious, keep exploring, and always keep wandering with us.
Source:
Behind Closed Doors - New England, Murder, New England - M.William Phelps

Ep. 51: Scalariously Wandering

Wicked Wanderings

08/21/24 • 95 min

GET YOUR WICKED WANDERINGS PODCAST MERCH NOW

Ever wondered what happens when you mix paranormal encounters, hard cider, and podcasting banter? Get ready for a rollicking ride as Hannah & Rob from Wicked Wanderings team up with John Olson & DW from The Scalarius Podcast. From swapping hilarious stories about getting plastered to debating the entertainment standards of Mr. Rogers and Tim Allen, this episode is packed with laughs and unexpected insights. You'll even hear about DW's preference for Cider Boys' hard cider and Melissa's contemplation of joining in the fun. The Valentine's Day banter will leave you chuckling as the hosts consider a special "betrothed" episode.
Ever thought Mr. Rogers' sweater changes were too slow for today's media? We sure did, and we’re breaking it down with humor and nostalgia. Then, we take a trip down memory lane, recounting the humble beginnings of our podcasts, the legal hurdles we jumped, and the equipment upgrades that made all the difference. Aspiring podcasters can glean useful tips on microphones and soundboards while enjoying our cautionary tale about using unauthorized audio. Plus, who could resist comparing our podcasting chemistry to the iconic characters of Die Hard?
But that's not all! We dive into ghost hunting adventures, haunted theaters, and our shared love for horror movies and true crime stories. Ever been to a historic cemetery in New England? We share our favorite spots and the intriguing tales behind some old gravestones. And let's not forget the lighter side of things, like our experiences with Greek festivals and fun food anecdotes. From haunted dolls in Sioux City to the chilling history of a family plagued by paranormal activity, this episode is a rollercoaster of spooky tales, personal connections, and lots of laughter. Join us for an unforgettable collaboration that's as entertaining as it is eerie!

Ep. 41: Hearsay and Horror in 1800s New Hampshire

Wicked Wanderings

06/12/24 • 19 min

Could a mere rumor lead to a man's execution? Join Hannah and Jess as we unravel the gripping murder trial of Daniel Davis Farmer from 1800s Manchester, New Hampshire, where hearsay played a pivotal role in one man's fate. This episode takes you through the chilling details of Anna and her daughter's brutal attack, with bloodied rocks and burn marks painting a haunting scene. We also scrutinize the public's fascination with the case and Daniel's alleged obsession with Anna, revealing how historical crimes were prosecuted in ways that might shock you today.
As we dissect the evidence—or lack thereof—against Daniel, we'll draw parallels to infamous cases like Lizzie Borden, highlighting the spectacle that trials often became in that era. Tune in for an engaging blend of true crime and historical analysis that promises to keep you riveted from start to finish.
Source:
Witness Statements in a Small New Hampshire Town - Murder, New England - M.William Phelps

🔒 Bonus Ep. 1: The Beverage Blunder Chronicles: Exploding Cans, Novelty Tops, and Cocaine Conundrums

Wicked Wanderings

04/21/24 • 2 min

Subscriber-only episode

Ever found yourself in a beverage blunder, wrestling with a can and ending up with more on your shirt than in your mouth? That's just the tip of the iceberg in our latest bonus podcast episode where the ordinary becomes extraordinary with each laugh-out-loud tale. Join us as we regale you with the kind of everyday escapades that turn into comedy gold. We're talking adult novelty items that'll have you questioning your drinking techniques, and trust me, you haven't lived until you've heard about the 'dick topper' incident.
Prepare for your sides to ache as we move from freeing the titties to the debate that never sleeps: is cocaine a sedative? Spoiler alert: it's not, and the discussion gets as wild as you'd imagine. Between Hannah's infectious stories and our mutual affinity for the absurd, you'll find yourself smack in the middle of conversations you never knew you needed. So clear your throat and steady your drink, because this episode is drenched in humor that's unapologetically raucous and brilliantly relatable.