Nassau vs. Suffolk: Who Has the Better Food? & The BEST Places to Eat on Long Island

Explicit content warning

04/23/25 • 39 min

We fired up The Oven and brought the Queen of Long Island eats herself — Gabby from Eating Long Island. In this mouthwatering episode, we’re talking viral April Fools pranks (shoutout to the fake In-N-Out news that broke Long Island), legendary burger wars (All American vs. In-N-Out, it gets heated), and Gabby’s 10-year rise from low-key food spammer to one of the Island’s most trusted taste-testers.

But it’s not all gravy — we get spicy:
- What’s the most overrated food on Long Island?
- Who’s slinging the best donuts in Suffolk?
- Should you ever put ice in red wine? (Spoiler: no.)
- Where are the cutest date spots for when Mario finally settles on one girl?

Plus: foodie red flags, fluff slander, Yelp beef, and Franco nearly fights a grandma slice. It’s unhinged. It’s honest. It’s delicious.

Chef’s Kiss or Chef’s Miss!
- Do you share milkshakes?
- Boneless wings: blessing or blasphemy?
- Is using a fork for sushi acceptable? (Gabby has thoughts.)

This is the ultimate Long Island foodie episode — funny, chaotic, and packed with real-deal recs. Hit play, get hungry, and don’t forget to spank that subscribe button.

#food #foodie #podcast #foodreview #longisland
The Oven Podcast: Subscribe!
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPkMPNPyCuaE8QVIKqRLSKg
Underdog Fantasy:
Use Promo Code "OVEN" at sign up and we'll match 50% of your deposit, up to $500 (Yes, that would mean an additional $250 from us!)
https://underdogfantasy.com
Dubby Energy:
Promo Code "OVEN" for 10% OFF
https://www.dubby.gg/
Betr Fantasy & Sportsbook:
Promo Code "OVEN200" for 100% Deposit Match up to $200
https://www.betr.app/
The Oven Merch / Shop:
https://www.theovenpod.com/category/all-products
The Oven Home Site:
https://www.theovenpod.com/
IG: theoven_pod / thefrancosphere / mario_theoven / 2xbakedny / eating_longisland
Tik Tok: theovenpod / eating_longisland
X: theoven_pod

Facebook: The Oven Podcast / Eating Long Island

YT: eating_longisland

eatinglongisland.com

Plus: foodie red flags, fluff slander, Yelp beef, and Franco nearly fights a grandma slice. It’s unhinged. It’s honest. It’s delicious.

Chef’s Kiss or Chef’s Miss!
- Do you share milkshakes?
- Boneless wings: blessing or blasphemy?
- Is using a fork for sushi acceptable? (Gabby has thoughts.)

This is the ultimate Long Island foodie episode — funny, chaotic, and packed with real-deal recs. Hit play, get hungry, and don’t forget to spank that subscribe button.

Facebook: The Oven Podcast / Eating Long Island

YT: eating_longisland

eatinglongisland.com

Previous Episode

What is "Medium Ugly"? Reviving Extinct Animals, Worst Kind of Travelers, & Recession-Proof Stocks?

Mini Oven 54: We start with a good laugh as Mario puts Franco on the spot, asking for his advice on recession-proof stocks and how to counteract the effects of Trump’s tariffs. We’re not that kind of show...
What’s cookin’ in The Oven today:
- They’ve revived the Dire Wolf, with that said, which animals would you bring back from extinction? Shoutout to THE Ray Romano, Woolly Mammoth, Carrier Pigeon, Hedwig, Sea Cow, Dodo Bird, Megalodon, Dinosaurs (did they really exist?), Woolly Rhinoceros, Saber-Toothed Tiger, & the Barbary Lion.
- The Oven is going to Tuscany?
- Which animal do you wish they replaced with the Dire Wolf? Mario is quick to say rats, or all rodents, and snakes. But Franco warns him that’s not a great idea and he should learn from Bryce Mitchell’s mistakes. He even says we shouldn’t kill spiders either because they help control other insect populations. Wait, Geese & Swans have teeth?! Franco’s getting rid of them first.
- Baseball season’s here and Mario wants to know Franco’s favorite Sunflower Seed flavors. We love Chinook Seedery & David Seeds.
- Which movies have the best soundtracks? Coach Carter, A Night at the Roxbury, The Hangover, Get Him to the Greek, Never Back Down, The Longest Yard, Kong: Skull Island, Shrek, & High School Musical. How about Adam Sandler’s decline?
- Apparently, Rob was a very talented singer in High School. He was in All County Chorus and NYSSMA. Franco vents about our old chorus teacher, Mrs. Conte.
- La Aroma de Cuba, hit us up! Mario loves their “El Jefe” & “Immensa” cigars & we wish they’d answer our DMs and emails.
- On Hinge, we have to compete with the hot guys and now ugly guys too?! Mario’s ability to look in and out of shape at the same time & his upcoming trip to Scottsdale. Should he delete Snapchat?
- Shoutout to Eric at Ridgewood Station Tavern: We never saw this Osama bin Laden 9/11 question coming...
- What kind of travelers annoy you? Hogging the armrest, leaning your seat back, & bringing a meal on a flight, FaceTiming in public without headphones, traveling in sandals or flip flops, eating halal on the train, bogging down the moving walkway, and taking up too much overhead space.
#funny #viralvideo #travel #podcast #movies
The Oven Podcast: Subscribe!
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPkMPNPyCuaE8QVIKqRLSKg
Underdog Fantasy:
Use Promo Code "OVEN" at sign up and we'll match 50% of your deposit, up to $500 (Yes, that would mean an additional $250 from us!)
https://underdogfantasy.com
Dubby Energy:
Promo Code "OVEN" for 10% OFF
https://www.dubby.gg/
Betr Fantasy & Sportsbook:
Promo Code "OVEN200" for 100% Deposit Match up to $200
https://www.betr.app/
The Oven Merch / Shop:
https://www.theovenpod.com/category/all-products
The Oven Home Site:
https://www.theovenpod.com/
IG: theoven_pod / thefrancosphere / mario_theoven / 2xbakedny
Tik Tok: theovenpod
X: theoven_pod
Facebook: The Oven Podcast

Next Episode

Inside the UFC’s Injury Epidemic: Fight Doctor EXPOSES What’s Really Going On | NBA Playoffs Chaos!

Coming to you from The Movement Underground in Seaford, NY with The Fight Doctor — Dr. Nicholas Giliberti.

We dive into:

Why UFC fighters are NEVER 100% healthy on fight night 😱
How cold plunges might be KILLING your muscle gains (Sauna vs Cold Plunge debate 🔥🧊)
The real reason sports injuries are at an ALL-TIME high 🚑
His work with UFC fighter Matt “SteamRolla” Frevola and other warriors 🥊
Street fight realities vs barstool bravado 💪🍻
NBA Playoffs 2025 predictions: Knicks vs Lakers dreams & Celtics “fraud check” 😂🏀
Building the PERFECT UFC fighter: Striking, wrestling, trash talk & chin durability (Spoiler: Chito Vera’s granite chin made the cut 😤)
Overrated UFC fighters? Michael Chandler... we’re talking to you 👀

Plus:
✅ Why good physical therapy isn’t just cookie-cutter stretches
✅ Insider gym stories you won’t hear anywhere else
✅ Why The Movement Underground is changing the rehab game forever

Stay till the end for some hilarious NBA trash talk, UFC hot takes, and a powerful convo about gratitude, faith, and chasing greatness. 🙏

#UFC #NBAPlayoffs #ColdPlunge #SaunaBenefits #InjuryPrevention #PhysicalTherapy

The Oven Podcast: Subscribe!
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPkMPNPyCuaE8QVIKqRLSKg
Underdog Fantasy:
Use Promo Code "OVEN" at sign up and we'll match 50% of your deposit, up to $500 (Yes, that would mean an additional $250 from us!)
https://underdogfantasy.com
Dubby Energy:
Promo Code "OVEN" for 10% OFF
https://www.dubby.gg/
Betr Fantasy & Sportsbook:
Promo Code "OVEN200" for 100% Deposit Match up to $200
https://www.betr.app/
The Oven Merch / Shop:
https://www.theovenpod.com/category/all-products
The Oven Home Site:
https://www.theovenpod.com/
IG: theoven_pod / thefrancosphere / mario_theoven / 2xbakedny / dr.nicholasgiliberti / warriorgarden / themovementunderground
Tik Tok: theovenpod
X: theoven_pod
Facebook: The Oven Podcast