The Murder Police Podcast

Send us a text

A split jury verdict that defied expectations. Three men dead. A defendant who confessed but later died by suicide in prison. The Lexington Triple Homicide conclusion reveals the devastating consequences when drug culture, family violence, and opportunity collide.
The detective's theory makes disturbing sense – victims who crashed hard after a "420 party" would have been unconscious when the shooter entered, explaining why neither woke when the other was killed. "People who do cocaine take the edge off with things that shut them down. It's how a lot of people actually die—they take speedballs," explains the James York from The 13th Floor Podcast, piecing together the timeline of this tragedy.
What unfolds in the courtroom proves equally compelling. The Department of Public Advocacy mounted an extraordinary defense, scrutinizing every piece of evidence through rarely-seen chain of custody hearings. Despite overwhelming ballistic evidence connecting all three murders to the same .38 caliber revolver found with Ricky, the jury delivered a stunning split decision – guilty of killing two victims but not his stepfather.
This case forces us to confront difficult questions about justice, extreme emotional disturbance as a legal defense, and the devastating ripple effects of violence. When Ricky later took his own life in prison, the tragedy claimed yet another victim, leaving his mother to grieve both her husband and son. His child would grow up without answers, and multiple families would be forever changed.
The weight of serving on a capital murder jury, the psychology behind split verdicts, and the lasting trauma on investigators and families alike – this episode explores it all while honoring the victims whose lives were cut tragically short. Listen now to understand what really happened in this haunting Kentucky case where everyone involved lost something precious.

Did you know that the episode you are about to listen to is available on YouTube as a full multicamera experience? Search for The Murder Police Podcast channel on YouTube, subscribe and see what you have been missing.

https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.
See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we delve into the heart-wrenching story of Letha, a young woman whose life was cut tragically short. This episode stands out not only for its compelling narrative but also for the emotional depth provided by our special guests, Miss Beverly and Patches, who were Letha’s aunt and cousin, respectively.
From the outset, listeners are cautioned about the graphic nature of the content, which includes violent assaults and murder. This warning sets the tone for an episode that is as raw as it is revealing. Miss Beverly and Patches take us back to their childhood, sharing fond memories of Letha, who was more like a daughter to Miss Beverly and a sister to Patches. These recollections paint a vivid picture of a vibrant young girl who loved playing in the creek, catching crawdads, and spending time with her family.
As Letha grew older, the dynamics within her family changed dramatically. Her father's sudden death from a heart attack left her feeling lost and anxious. This sense of instability was exacerbated when her mother remarried and moved away, leaving Letha and her brother to fend for themselves. The episode poignantly captures Letha’s struggle to find her footing in a world that seemed increasingly uncertain.
One of the most gripping moments comes when Miss Beverly recounts the last time she saw Letha. She describes how Letha seemed unusually anxious and sad, a stark contrast to the lively girl she once knew. This sense of foreboding only deepens when Patches reveals that Letha had confided in her about being afraid of certain people who frequented her home. Despite these warning signs, no one could have predicted the tragic turn of events that would soon unfold.
The investigation into Letha’s disappearance is meticulously detailed, highlighting the exhaustive efforts made by her family and the police to find her. From missing posters to search parties, the community rallied together, but it wasn’t until months later that the grim reality of Letha’s fate was confirmed. This search for answers and the subsequent discovery of her body is a sobering reminder of the fragility of life and the devastating impact of violence.
Throughout the episode, the host, Wendy Lyons, handles the narrative with sensitivity and respect, ensuring that Letha’s story is told with the dignity it deserves. They also provide valuable insights into the broader implications of such tragedies, emphasizing the importance of community support and the relentless pursuit of justice.
For true crime enthusiasts, this episode is a must-listen. It offers a compelling blend of personal anecdotes, investigative details, and emotional depth that will leave listeners both moved and informed. Tune in to the Murder Police Podcast to hear the full story and honor the memory of Letha, a young woman whose life and legacy continue to resonate.

Did you know that the episode you are about to listen to is available on YouTube as a full multicamera experience? Search for The Murder Police Podcast channel on YouTube, subscribe and see what you have been missing.

https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.
See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

A young man's mysterious disappearance has left a community in turmoil and a family in search of answers. Timothy Sterner's story is one of heartache, resilience, and the relentless pursuit of truth. We are joined by his uncle Terrance and grandmother Sandy, who share not only personal stories and cherished memories of Timmy but also the immense void his absence has left in their lives. Sandy opens up about the role of faith and love in navigating through the darkest times, while Terrence recounts the joy of teaching Timmy to ride a motorcycle, a testament to Timmy's adventurous spirit.
Timmy's life was a complex tapestry of challenges and hidden talents. Despite facing battles with substance abuse and trust issues, his prowess on the football field shone brightly. We discuss the pride his family felt when a coach recognized his potential, paving the way for moments of achievement that Timmy cherished, such as the excitement surrounding an award ceremony at school. Through these tales, we highlight the importance of guidance and support, underscoring the lasting impact Timmy had on those around him even in times of adversity.
The search for Little Timmy remains fraught with frustration and unanswered questions. As Terrence outlines his ongoing quest for closure amid the discovery of Timmy's car near a wreck site, the emotional toll on the family becomes palpable. The community's efforts to piece together what happened are marred by a lack of cooperation from those last seen with Timmy, leaving a cloud of confusion and heartbreak that lingers. Join us as we capture the family's unwavering hope for resolution and peace in a community determined to uncover the truth.

Did you know that the episode you are about to listen to is available on YouTube as a full multicamera experience? Search for The Murder Police Podcast channel on YouTube, subscribe and see what you have been missing.

https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.
See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

Missing: Michael Keith Gorley | Part 1 of 2 | December 14, 2021

Missing: Michael Keith Gorley | Part 2 of 2 | December 21, 2021

On May 17, 2015, 38 year old Michael Keith Gorley, a son, a brother and a father, told his mother good bye as he left the house. Michael never returned home. He was last seen on Highway 300, or Knob Lick Road, in Stanford Kentucky.

The Murder Police Podcast offers a two-part series on Michael’s missing case, to let people know who Michael is to his family, and to keep hope alive that he will be found.

Michael’s family believes Michael is dead, already erecting a gravestone in the local cemetery and pre-paying for inevitable funeral arrangements. Michael’s case is particularly frustrating given that there is a witnessed last known location and tight time frame, however, the investigators and family also face a cold silence from people that potentially know what happened to Michael and where he is.

Listen to these episodes to hear Michael’s mother, Sandra Hasty, and sister, Jennifer Gorley Coffey tell us who Michael is, and take us through the strange things that happened in the wake of his going missing.

Also, we talk to retired career cop and now private investigator Mike Ward, about his role and efforts in locating Michael.

Once you have listened, share this as much as you can, especially if you live anywhere near, or know anyone from Lincoln and Boyle Counites in Kentucky. Once you have listened, you will know why we ask.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.
See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

The autopsy. In the world of True Crime, this examination of the victim of a crime, after death, may be one of the last and elusive mysteries in the genre.

Sure, we can get copies of part or most of this post-mortem examination and try to wrap our heads around the details, but those reports never will explain anything about why the autopsy is performed (or not), who performs the exam and why she got interested in such a unique, may intimidating career and whether or not she is affected by performing possibly countless examinations, covering the gamut of our physical condition after we die.

Follow The Murder Police Podcast on a 3-part journey into this fascinating world as we interview Dr. Craig Davis about how he became interested in Forensic Pathology, his education and career track and most importantly, what this career has meant to him.

We know that if you follow The Murder Police Podcast and are in our tribe, you want more than just a story, you are with us to learn. So, pull up a chair, go for a drive, or jog, or walk, and learn with us. This is the only place where you can letter, in True Crime..
Click HERE for Show Notes

Forensic Pathology with Dr. Greg Davis | Part 1 of 3 | September 14, 2021

Forensic Pathology with Dr. Greg Davis | Part 2 of 3 | September 14, 2021

Forensic Pathology with Dr. Greg Davis | Part 3 of 3 | September 14, 2021

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.
See what you have been missing on YouTube!