Scare Me Straight
Alexa, Nichole, and Jonathan
All episodes
Best episodes
Seasons
Top 10 Scare Me Straight Episodes
Goodpods has curated a list of the 10 best Scare Me Straight episodes, ranked by the number of listens and likes each episode have garnered from our listeners. If you are listening to Scare Me Straight for the first time, there's no better place to start than with one of these standout episodes. If you are a fan of the show, vote for your favorite Scare Me Straight episode by adding your comments to the episode page.
Ed Gein The Butcher of Plainfield
Scare Me Straight
05/06/24 • 48 min
Ohhhh Scaremestraight listenerssssssssss!
What a lovely...skin suit you have... a divine sku... I mean head. What beautiful fingies too.
Take a guess who! This week we are diving into the darker side of small-town life! Join us as we explore the twisted tale of Ed Gein, the 'Butcher of Plainfield.'
From farmhouse oddities to his eye for fashion, this episode will leave you both intrigued and slightly spooked! Don't miss out on the creepiest conversation of the week!
Jeffrey Dahmer - The Milwaukee Cannibal | Part 2
Scare Me Straight
03/13/25 • 61 min
We’re baaaa - insert Mariah Carey whistle tone - aaaaacccckkkkk!! And we missed all you spooky bitches real, reeaaal bad.
Let’s pick up where we left off, shall we? We’ve got another killer episode detailing the life of Jeffrey Dahmer, and it’s a doozy. Buckle up friends because it’s... intense. We’re in our season 3 era and we can’t wait!
This episode of "Scare Me Straight" contains graphic descriptions of violence, murder, and cannibalism that some listeners may find disturbing. The content discussed includes detailed accounts of serial killings, psychological manipulation, and explicit references to the crimes committed by Jeffrey Dahmer. Listener discretion is strongly advised, especially for those sensitive to topics of extreme violence and trauma. If you feel uncomfortable with such content, we recommend skipping this episode. Your mental well-being is important to us.
Eastern Airlines Flight 401
Scare Me Straight
01/12/24 • 44 min
Oh listenerssss! Are you ready for a little vay-cay?!
Well... after this episode you might not be... This week on Scaremestraight we are diving right into the Flight of 401 and the ghosties that follow! We love a traveling girlie. But not everyone feels that way!
Please fasten your seat belts, raise your window shades, and remain in your seat for take off because we aren’t liable for ya’ll.
Legend of the Mothman
Scare Me Straight
12/06/23 • 36 min
Hello dear followers!
Are you ready for another cryptids episode? This week we are unmasking the extra ooky spooky MOTHMAN. 🦋👹🦋 ✨✨ We’ve got stories. We’ve got pictures. We’ve got some off the wall theories. Is he an alien? Is he a monster? A prankster?
Also, with mothman being so popular who would have thought he was so mysterious?!
Join us this week for a fun little cryptid kiki!
Submersible Event & Titanic Conspiracy Theories
Scare Me Straight
06/28/23 • 57 min
🚨 Attention listeners! New episode alert! 🚨
This week we are diving into the mysteries, conspiracies, and total diva-ness of the Titanic herself. Was she actually the Olympic? Should someone have taken a look at those lifeboats? And WHO was in charge of the radio messages?! The ocean is spooky enough but throw in some ice bergs and sugar we are going DOWN.
Carl Tanzler's Obsession
Scare Me Straight
06/21/23 • 40 min
In this gripping episode, we delve into the macabre tale of Carl Tanzler and his infamous corpse bride. Join us as we uncover the chilling true story that shocked a small Florida town in the 1930s.
Tarot Card Reading | What is Our Life Purpose?
Scare Me Straight
05/27/24 • 48 min
Scaremestraight listeners...
We’ve consulted the cards...
and we’ve learned that we’re...
fabulous! ✨🃏🔮
This week we have a special episode, and although not too spooky, there were a couple of wig snatches! Join us as we do a lil’ tarot and read into our futures. Will we laugh? Cry? Slay? Come listen and find out. ✨
The Exorcism of Roland Doe - Part 3
Scare Me Straight
03/08/24 • 46 min
Hey Scaremestraight friends! We hope you’re ready because we’ve got a three parter, and it’s coming today. 👻👻 The chilling conclusion to our journey into the darkness of the exorcism of Roland Doe is finally here!
🕯️🔮 In this final chapter, we witness the ultimate battle between good and evil as priests attempt to rid Roland of the demonic forces that have taken hold of him. The stakes are high, the tension palpable, and the outcome uncertain. Will the power of faith and prayer be enough to save Roland's soul? Or will the darkness prevail? ⚔️💫
Stay spooky!
Show more best episodes
Show more best episodes
FAQ
How many episodes does Scare Me Straight have?
Scare Me Straight currently has 49 episodes available.
What topics does Scare Me Straight cover?
The podcast is about Scary, Fiction, Aliens, History, Creepy, Paranormal, Podcasts, Ghosts, Science Fiction and Haunted.
What is the most popular episode on Scare Me Straight?
The episode title 'Ed Gein The Butcher of Plainfield' is the most popular.
What is the average episode length on Scare Me Straight?
The average episode length on Scare Me Straight is 50 minutes.
How often are episodes of Scare Me Straight released?
Episodes of Scare Me Straight are typically released every 7 days, 21 hours.
When was the first episode of Scare Me Straight?
The first episode of Scare Me Straight was released on Feb 8, 2023.
Show more FAQ
Show more FAQ