Log in

goodpods headphones icon

To access all our features

Open the Goodpods app
Close icon
headphones
Playing Teacher

Playing Teacher

Matthew Cade and Rob Monahan

🎙️ What is a teacher, really?
And what’s it actually like inside a New York City school?

Welcome to Playing Teacher, where veteran educators Matt and Rob—with over 40 years of combined experience teaching in NYC—pull back the curtain on the myths, realities, and moments that make education unforgettable (for better or worse). From the mysterious teacher’s lounge to the myth of “summer off,” they explore what really happens when the classroom door closes.

This isn’t a shiny brochure version of school. It’s the real deal:
đź§  Learning vs. schooling.
❤️ What kids actually carry with them.
🔥 How teachers and counselors survive systems built to burn them out.

And when we’re lucky enough to have her, we’re joined by Beanie—school counselor, educator, and recurring co-host—who brings powerful insight, grounded compassion, and the kind of perspective only someone who's worked both inside and around the classroom can offer.

👥 Guests range from teachers, students, and administrators to learning scientists, former kids (yes, really), and other unexpected voices from the world of education.

Whether you're in the classroom, supporting from the sidelines, or just trying to make sense of how we learn and why it matters—this is your hallway pass to the inside.

Share icon

All episodes

Best episodes

Seasons

Top 10 Playing Teacher Episodes

Goodpods has curated a list of the 10 best Playing Teacher episodes, ranked by the number of listens and likes each episode have garnered from our listeners. If you are listening to Playing Teacher for the first time, there's no better place to start than with one of these standout episodes. If you are a fan of the show, vote for your favorite Playing Teacher episode by adding your comments to the episode page.

Playing Teacher - Episode 8: Teaching and Learning During COVID in NYC
play

04/10/25 • 53 min

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we rewind to one of the most surreal, exhausting, and defining chapters in modern education: COVID in New York City. Teaching during the pandemic wasn’t just about pivoting to Zoom—it was about surviving, adapting, and finding humanity in the chaos.

We talk candidly about what it meant to be an educator when the world shut down: the scrambled emails, the lost students, the tech failures, the eerie silence of empty classrooms. But we also talk about the grit, the creativity, and the small, quiet victories—like the student who turned on their camera for the first time, or the day a class full of muted icons finally laughed in unison.

We explore how the pandemic didn’t just test our ability to teach—it forced us to reimagine what learning could look like, and what school even meant. From digital access disparities to the emotional weight of teaching through trauma, this episode captures both the cracks in the system and the light that somehow got through.

This one’s for the teachers who taught through tears, through masks, through screen fatigue—and who found new ways to connect, inspire, and hold space when the world felt like it was falling apart.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Playing Teacher - Episode 3: The Hook: The Art of Captivation
play

04/09/25 • 42 min

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we dive into The Hook—that elusive, electric moment when a teacher pulls students in and makes them want to learn. It’s the magic trick, the spark, the wink across the room that says, “This is going to be good.” But here’s the thing: it’s not in the lesson plan template, and it sure doesn’t show up on most rubrics.

Too often dismissed as fluff or misunderstood by administrators and even some teachers, The Hook is actually one of the most powerful tools in a great educator’s arsenal. It’s where the art of teaching lives—and where performance, storytelling, and human connection meet academic content.

With Matt’s background in acting and performance and Rob’s deep roots in science and game-based learning, we explore how great teachers captivate curiosity, build anticipation, and transform classrooms into stages where every kid wants a front-row seat.

This one’s for the teachers who know that sometimes, the best way to teach a standard is to make it feel like a story worth showing up for.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Playing Teacher - Episode 2: Preps and Lunches (and Superpong)
play

04/09/25 • 36 min

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, Matt, Rob, and Brugge crack open one of the most sacred and underrated parts of the school day: preps and lunches. More than just breaks, these windows of time were life-saving lifelines in the relentless hustle of NYC public school teaching. We reflect on how these moments offered space to breathe, plan, decompress—or just stare into the void with a slice of pizza in hand.

But it wasn’t all quiet recovery. Sometimes, it was survival through play. Enter Superpong—a game we invented during our lunch breaks that blended absurdity, competition, and much-needed laughter. Part coping mechanism, part creative rebellion, Superpong became our ritual, our reset, and occasionally... our battleground.

Tune in for stories from the teacher trenches, the weird things that keep you sane, and the essential truth that sometimes the best professional development happens with a paddle in your hand and a chicken patty on your tray.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Playing Teacher - Episode 1: The "Expert" Teacher
play

09/06/24 • 91 min

Send us a text

“Ok, if it’s so easy you teach my class..please show me the way.” Ah, the fantasy of every teacher. Imagine a scenario where you’re told to change roles and write up your supervisor who wants to show you how it’s done...you know because they were once an “expert teacher.” But what if it bombs? Matt and Rob relive this once in a teacher’s lifetime experiment and discuss better alternatives to how teachers are evaluated. More importantly, who is qualified to make these evaluations?

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we unpack one of the most familiar — and controversial — strategies in elementary education: rewards and incentives. From treasure boxes and pizza parties to Dojo points and public praise, we examine how these practices shape student motivation, behavior, and identity in the classroom. Are we inspiring effort — or cultivating compliance? Are extrinsic rewards helpful stepping stones or long-term obstacles to deeper learning and self-regulation?
Whether you're a teacher filling sticker charts or a parent wondering about prize-based learning, this episode offers practical insights and philosophical food for thought.
🎧 Available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.
#MotivationMatters #GameBasedLearning #ClassroomCulture #PlayingTeacherPodcast

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Send us a text

🎙️ Playing Teacher Ep. 10 – Pacing, Pop Culture, and the 30-Second Reprimand

Description:

In this episode of Playing Teacher, Matt recounts a jaw-dropping moment when he was called out in front of students for returning to class 30 seconds late after using the bathroom—yes, 30 seconds. Jeannine and Robert reflect on how often teachers are denied even the most basic human grace. This leads into a dynamic, often hilarious discussion on classroom pacing, student rapport, and when to stick to the script—or throw it out.

đź’ˇ Robert dives into differentiated pacing styles in teaching and media (yes, including a failed Rocky III clip attempt), drawing sharp parallels between instructional flow and burnout. Jeannine shares her perspective as a counselor working with IEP students, emphasizing structure, routine, and emotional awareness.

🔬 We also go deep on:

  • How pacing affects testing outcomes and engagement
  • Teaching in urban schools and DIY curriculum hacks
  • Being observed under the Danielson Framework and its impact on authenticity
  • What teachers can learn from Disney's “plusing” philosophy of continuous improvement
  • Why student mindset matters more than any calendar

Oh—and in a twist no one saw coming, Jeannine finds out her glowing podcast review was written by... an AI.

🎧 Perfect for educators, ed leaders, and anyone who's ever wondered what really goes on behind the classroom door. This one blends laughs, real talk, and pedagogical gold.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we talk about the moments that stick—the scenes from our lives as educators that play in our minds like movies. You know the ones: the hallway showdown, the field trip fiasco, the spontaneous dance party, the kid who said something so profound you wrote it on a post-it and never threw it away.

We reflect on how these memorable teaching moments—big or small, funny or moving—aren’t just one-off stories. They’re what give the work meaning. And much like scenes from iconic films, they become part of our shared consciousness, shaping how we connect, how we teach, and how we remember.

From epic fails to unexpected victories, we draw parallels between the classroom and the big screen. Because whether you’re quoting Dead Poets Society, The Goonies, or Ferris Bueller, there’s something powerful about how movies and memories intertwine. They help us build language, build relationships, and build meaning—especially with kids who need more than just content; they need connection.

This one’s for the teachers who carry a mental highlight reel—and who know that sometimes, the best way to reach a student is through a well-timed movie quote or a shared laugh that becomes legend.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we talk about something every educator feels at some point—what it means to be yourself in a school system that often prefers you to color inside the lines. Whether it’s pushing against outdated norms, teaching in ways that aren’t “in the handbook,” or simply showing up as your full, weird, passionate self, going against the grain can make you stand out... and not always in the way people like.

We unpack the moments when being authentic can make you unpopular—with administrators, with coworkers, or with the “system.” And we reflect on the quiet courage it takes to keep showing up as yourself, even when the easier route would be to conform.

From hallway politics to unconventional lesson plans, from dress code subversions to the subtle art of staying out of faculty cliques, we explore how hard—and how vital—it is to do it your way. As Frank Sinatra said, regrets, I’ve had a few... but then again, too few to mention.

This one’s for the teachers who’d rather be real than be liked. Who show up, speak up, and shake things up. And who know that sometimes, doing it your way is the only way to stay sane, stay passionate, and stay in the game.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Send us a text

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we pull back the curtain on a not-so-secret weapon in our teaching toolbox: cinema. Whether we were screening something in our makeshift movie theater during lunch or showing a film to an entire class, movies weren’t just a break—they were world-builders.

But this episode isn’t about the obvious curriculum tie-ins (you won’t hear us talking about “let’s watch October Sky during the space unit”). Instead, we explore how film can plant vivid experiences in kids’ minds—scenes, emotions, and stories that become internal reference points. These are the seeds that later bloom into understanding when we reach for analogies, metaphors, or that elusive “aha” moment in science class.

Movies, when used well, help create a shared cultural language in the classroom. They give us shortcuts to explain complex ideas (“remember how The Matrix slows time?”), and more importantly, they give our students memories that feel real—even if they happened on screen.

This episode is a love letter to the big screen and a reminder that sometimes, the most powerful teaching tool is the one that dims the lights and starts with a flicker.

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Playing Teacher - Episode 5: Are We Okay? (Spoiler: Probably Not)
play

04/09/25 • 58 min

Send us a text

Teaching, Sanity, and the Fine Line Between Passion and Burnout

In this episode of Playing Teacher, we ask the question that lingers behind every empty coffee cup, every hallway meltdown, and every wildly creative bulletin board at 2AM: Are we okay?

Spoiler alert: probably not.

We take a lighthearted but honest look at the emotional rollercoaster that is life in the classroom. We talk about the toll teaching can take on your mental health—not in a clinical, diagnostic way, but in the way teachers actually talk about it: the “I think I laughed and cried at the same time today” kind of way.

We also get real about the culture of self-sacrifice in education, how humor becomes a survival skill, and the fine line between being dedicated and being depleted. Along the way, we unpack whether teaching draws in people who are a little offbeat to begin with—or whether the system itself slowly erodes your sanity.

It’s funny, it’s therapeutic, and it’s a reminder that taking care of yourself is not a luxury—it’s a requirement if we’re going to keep showing up for kids and for each other.

This one’s for the teachers who’ve ever looked in the mirror during their prep and whispered, “Am I okay?”—and for anyone who’s ever answered, “Not really... but I’m still here.”

Support the show

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Show more best episodes

Toggle view more icon

FAQ

How many episodes does Playing Teacher have?

Playing Teacher currently has 10 episodes available.

What topics does Playing Teacher cover?

The podcast is about Learning, Music Education, Society & Culture, Teaching, Podcasts, Education, Science, Philosophy and Teacher.

What is the most popular episode on Playing Teacher?

The episode title 'Episode 7: Remember When… (Memorable Moments & Movie Magic)' is the most popular.

What is the average episode length on Playing Teacher?

The average episode length on Playing Teacher is 57 minutes.

How often are episodes of Playing Teacher released?

Episodes of Playing Teacher are typically released every 1 day, 8 hours.

When was the first episode of Playing Teacher?

The first episode of Playing Teacher was released on Sep 6, 2024.

Show more FAQ

Toggle view more icon

Comments