
It's Everyday with John and Jay
John and Jay
We're the unapologetically raw comedy podcast that’s not afraid to push boundaries. Packed with outrageous skits, off-the-cuff banter, and original songs, John and Jay bring their no-holds-barred humor to everyday topics, wild hypotheticals, and everything in between. Whether you’re here for belly laughs or pure chaos, this is the ultimate shoot-the-shit show for anyone who loves their comedy a little rough around the edges
Check out our official merch store! shop.backinthedaypodcast.com
All episodes
Best episodes
Seasons
Top 10 It's Everyday with John and Jay Episodes
Goodpods has curated a list of the 10 best It's Everyday with John and Jay episodes, ranked by the number of listens and likes each episode have garnered from our listeners. If you are listening to It's Everyday with John and Jay for the first time, there's no better place to start than with one of these standout episodes. If you are a fan of the show, vote for your favorite It's Everyday with John and Jay episode by adding your comments to the episode page.

Episode 174: The Rabbit Hole of Obscure Bands and Nostalgic Metal
It's Everyday with John and Jay
06/02/25 • 72 min
Ready to watch two passionate metalheads go down the rabbit hole of obscure bands, Metallica deep cuts, and unfiltered comedy? This episode takes you on a musical adventure you won't forget.
John and Jay kick things off by discussing a potential recording opportunity for their band, weighing the merits of a surprisingly affordable studio package that includes recording, mixing, and mastering. Their excitement is tempered with the healthy skepticism of musicians who've learned that if something sounds too good to be true, it usually is—but this opportunity might just be the real deal.
The conversation shifts to an extensive analysis of Metallica's controversial 2003 album "St. Anger." The hosts dissect why the album was initially maligned (that infamous trash-can snare sound!) while arguing for its importance as a creative stepping stone in the band's evolution. "St. Anger crawled so Death Magnetic could run," they conclude, showcasing their ability to appreciate the nuances of a divisive release. This segment shines with genuine passion as they compare studio and live recordings, highlighting how production choices dramatically impact an album's reception.
The most entertaining portion arrives when the hosts embark on a journey of musical discovery, searching YouTube for underground industrial and metal bands. Their authentic reactions to discovering gems like After Dusk, Gloomlight, and The Cold Shoulder capture the pure joy of finding new music. "It's like discovering an artifact that hasn't been found yet," they marvel, sharing their excitement with listeners who might be seeking fresh sounds beyond mainstream metal.
The episode wraps with updates on personal health journeys and upcoming endeavors, including a job interview and radio appearance. Throughout it all, John and Jay maintain their signature blend of humor, insight, and unabashed enthusiasm that keeps listeners coming back for more.
Whether you're a dedicated metalhead or simply enjoy authentic conversations between friends, hit subscribe and join us each week for more musical explorations, comedy, and unfiltered takes on the things we love.
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 126: Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) // Indiana Jones...Badass!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
07/02/24 • 72 min
Grab your fedora and whip, nostalgia buffs! This week on Back in the Day with John and Jay, we're journeying back to 1981 to uncover the timeless adventure of Raiders of the Lost Ark. Join us as we delve into the epic quest of the one and only Indiana Jones, played by the legendary Harrison Ford.
John and Jay will guide you through the thrilling plot where our daring archaeologist races against time (and Nazis) to locate the biblical Ark of the Covenant. We'll break down the film's heart-pounding action scenes, from the iconic boulder chase to the explosive finale, and discuss why these moments continue to set the standard for adventure films today.
Get ready for a treasure trove of fun facts and behind-the-scenes stories. We'll chat about Steven Spielberg’s direction, George Lucas’s story creation, and the incredible special effects that brought ancient booby traps and supernatural forces to life. Plus, we’ll highlight the unforgettable supporting cast, including Karen Allen as the fiery Marion Ravenwood and Paul Freeman as the sinister Dr. René Belloq.
Friends of the Show
1 Man Mafia (twitch.tv/1man_mafia)
Jayke The Gamer God (twitch.tv/JaykeTheGamerGod)
IB Best Gaming (https://www.tiktok.com/@ibbestgaming)
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 151: Fantasy Football Semifinal Shenanigans // Karate Kid Comebacks and a Macaulay Culkin Misadventure!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
12/23/24 • 80 min
Ever wondered what happens when your fantasy football strategy feels like a scene from an old EA Sports game? Join us, John and Jay, as we ride the emotional rollercoaster of reaching the semifinals in our fantasy league. Our conversation spins from the joy of unexpected player performances to the more serious side of college sports, tackling the complexities of the transfer portal and the hot topics of athlete compensation. With laughter and lively debates, we question if NIL deals are shifting the heart of college athletics, making it more about the money than the game itself.
But wait, there's more! We take a sideways leap into the entertainment world, sharing our mixed feelings on the freshest Karate Kid movie trailer. Our love for Cobra Kai fuels a humorous speculation about potential crossover scenarios and the future of the franchise. The hilarity continues as we parody the vintage "Lawrence Welk Show," celebrating Fred Armisen's comedic genius, and indulge in a nostalgic tribute to "Chitty Chitty Bang Bang" while marveling at Dick Van Dyke's timeless performances. Our musical musings don't stop there—brace yourselves for a critique of the audacious fusion of country and metal, peppered with tales from the vibrant life of a wedding DJ.
And just when you thought things couldn't get any more unexpected, we recount our recent adventure at a Macaulay Culkin event that didn't quite hit the mark. From awkward venue setups to reminiscing "Home Alone" scenes, our evening took a delightful turn with a memorable dining experience at Crave. This episode is a whirlwind of sports, movies, and music filled with humor and insights that will leave you chuckling and reflecting long after the credits roll.
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 100: Toy Story (1995) // EPISODE 100 WOOOOOO!!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
01/02/24 • 69 min
Thanks for all the support as we reach our 100th episode! A running joke we've been doing over the last several months is saying we are going to do Toy Story for the next week's episode with no intensions of actually doing it. Well, you're in luck, because we are doing it for EPISODE 1-0-0!!!!!
Toy Story" is a groundbreaking animated film that introduces audiences to a world where toys come to life when humans aren't around. The story centers around Woody, a cowboy doll who has always been the favorite toy of his owner, Andy. However, Woody's world is turned upside down when Andy receives a new space ranger action figure, Buzz Lightyear, as a birthday gift.
Buzz quickly becomes the new favorite, leading to a rivalry between Woody and Buzz for Andy's affection. In a twist of fate, both toys find themselves outside of the comfort of Andy's room and must navigate the challenges of the real world together. As they encounter perils like sadistic neighbor Sid and the mysterious claw-wielding aliens in a pizza parlor, Woody and Buzz discover the true meaning of friendship and loyalty.
"Toy Story" is not just a tale of animated adventure; it's a heartwarming exploration of the bonds between toys and their owners, emphasizing themes of acceptance, belonging, and the passage of time. With its innovative use of computer animation, endearing characters, and a witty script, "Toy Story" became a landmark film in animation history, setting the stage for Pixar's future success and earning a special place in the hearts of audiences worldwide.
Check out the merch: http://shop.backinthedaypodcast.com
Friends of the Show
1 Man Mafia (twitch.tv/1man_mafia)
Jayke The Gamer God (twitch.tv/JaykeTheGamerGod)
IB Best Gaming (https://www.tiktok.com/@ibbestgaming)
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 165: Small Town Laughs: Weight Loss, Wrestling, and Controversial Dreams
It's Everyday with John and Jay
04/04/25 • 69 min
Two friends with absolutely no filter take you on a wild conversational journey through the everyday absurdities of life in small-town Ohio.
This episode captures John and Jay at their uncensored best as they navigate topics ranging from serious business ventures to uncomfortably hilarious personal stories. John shares his ambitious journey toward purchasing a beloved local game store, revealing the surprising support he's found within the community banking system and downtown business network. His passionate commitment to preserving an important local establishment shines through as he details contingency plans and potential partnerships.
The conversation takes several unexpected turns, including a candid discussion of their successful weight loss journeys - John proudly shares his 17-pound accomplishment while his co-host celebrates dropping over 14 pounds. Their mutual accountability system offers a glimpse into the genuine friendship that makes this podcast so engaging.
When the topic shifts to a recent local wrestling event that Jay DJ'd for, listeners get treated to hilarious behind-the-scenes insights into the indie wrestling world - from Thunder Dick's entrance music to wrestlers changing costumes in shared spaces. Their metal music review segment captures authentic first reactions to bands like Wage War and Otep, complete with impromptu comparisons to movie soundtracks.
Perhaps most memorably, Jay recounts an awkward dream involving his wife and John's brother that sparked real-world conversations - demonstrating the hosts' remarkable willingness to share even their most embarrassing moments. Through it all, their distinctive brand of humor and honesty creates an experience that feels like joining two friends for an evening of unscripted entertainment.
Subscribe now to experience the uncensored comedy and real conversations that have listeners coming back every week!
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 157: Techno Tunes and AI Creations Collide in a Musical Adventure!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
02/04/25 • 66 min
Craving a techno beat to spice up your podcast intros? We've got you covered! Our escapades with AI in creating a techno-metal fusion intro are as unpredictable as securing that must-have item from GameStop. Discover our love for Electric Cowboy's latest earworm and our amusing speculations about their Eurovision potential. The fun doesn't stop with music; we also reveal our astonishing delight in finding a Boosie-featured country tune. Get ready for a wild ride through unexpected music, movie chatter about classics like "Waterboy," and the delightful chaos of crafting the perfect podcast intro.
AI-generated music is here, and we're diving headfirst into its whimsical possibilities! Imagine a West Coast gangster rap about Legos or a metalcore anthem dedicated to Kraft macaroni and cheese—both brought to life with a dash of AI creativity. As we navigate the ethical concerns and quirky surprises of AI in music, laughter and nostalgia abound. Whether you're intrigued by AI's ability to mimic iconic artists or simply enjoy the bizarre joy of crafting lyrics on unusual topics, this episode promises a hilarious exploration of music, technology, and the unexpected twists that keep us entertained.
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 85: The Naked Gun // It's Enrique Polazzo!!!!!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
09/20/23 • 68 min
In this episode, we'll dive deep into the hilarious world of "The Naked Gun." We'll dissect its slapstick comedy, offbeat characters, and uproarious sight gags. From the memorable "nice beaver" exchange to the unforgettable baseball game mayhem, we'll break down the scenes that had us in stitches.
But it's not just about the gags; we'll also talk about the brilliant cast, including Priscilla Presley as the love interest, Ricardo Montalban as the outlandish villain, and O.J. Simpson in a role that's as unexpected as it is comical. And of course the brilliant Leslie Nielsen.
We'll share our favorite moments, the most quotable lines, and how "The Naked Gun" has aged like a fine, uproarious wine. Plus, we'll discuss its lasting influence on comedy films and TV shows that followed.
Friends of the Show
1 Man Mafia (twitch.tv/1man_mafia)
Jayke The Gamer God (twitch.tv/JaykeTheGamerGod)
IB Best Gaming (https://www.tiktok.com/@ibbestgaming)
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 115: The Cable Guy (1996) // I just want to hang out...NO BIG DEAAAL!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
04/16/24 • 70 min
The term "underrated" get thrown out a lot. But this film truly encompasses that term.
In "The Cable Guy," a dark comedy directed by Ben Stiller, a lonely and socially awkward cable installer named Chip Douglas, played by Jim Carrey, develops an unhealthy obsession with one of his customers, Steven Kovacs, portrayed by Matthew Broderick. Steven just wants a simple cable installation, but Chip sees an opportunity to fill the void in his life by befriending Steven, despite Steven's reluctance.
As Chip's behavior becomes increasingly intrusive and erratic, Steven tries to distance himself, but Chip's relentless pursuit only escalates. Chip inserts himself into Steven's life, disrupting his relationships and manipulating situations to keep Steven dependent on him. Along the way, Chip's troubled past and psychological instability come to light, revealing a deeply disturbed individual beneath his affable facade.
The film explores themes of loneliness, obsession, and the blurred boundaries between friendship and manipulation. Carrey's performance as the unhinged Cable Guy is both hilarious and chilling, showcasing his versatility as an actor. "The Cable Guy" serves as a satirical commentary on the pervasiveness of media culture and the dangers of unchecked obsession in a digital age.
Friends of the Show
1 Man Mafia (twitch.tv/1man_mafia)
Jayke The Gamer God (twitch.tv/JaykeTheGamerGod)
IB Best Gaming (https://www.tiktok.com/@ibbestgaming)
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 15: Cedar Point...America's Roller Coast!
It's Everyday with John and Jay
05/09/22 • 65 min
Get to the Point!
Living in Northwest Ohio, summer time was filled with cookouts, baseball games, going to the pool ect. But there was only one place where you can really get your summer on and that was Cedar Point! We talk about our favorite rides and attractions over the years. Plus, as a bonus, we have John's brother Joey on the show to talk about his time working at Cedar Point. Plus much more!!!
This week's "During the Break":
-Song parody of Def Leppard's - "Love Bites" called "Bug Bites".
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford

Episode 173: My Underwear Was A Crime Scene: Tales From The Road
It's Everyday with John and Jay
06/02/25 • 67 min
Raw, unfiltered, and delightfully chaotic – that's what awaits you in this episode as John and Jay take listeners on another wild ride through their week's adventures and random musings.
Jay kicks things off with exciting news about his DJ business scoring a radio promotion opportunity on 96.7 The Mix, showcasing his entrepreneurial hustle. The conversation flows naturally into a nostalgic discussion about recording songs off the radio – remember holding those microphones up to speakers and praying no one would talk during your favorite song? Today's streaming generation will never understand the struggle!
Things take an interesting turn when the hosts dive into the darker side of social media, discussing controversial AI filters creating fake Down syndrome content. Their commentary, while adult-oriented and boundary-pushing, raises legitimate questions about digital ethics and exploitation in today's algorithm-driven world.
In a surprisingly vulnerable segment, both hosts open up about their experiences with compression shirts and body confidence. It's a refreshingly honest conversation about male body image that balances self-deprecating humor with genuine insights about personal growth and acceptance.
The episode continues with stories about Jay's successful wedding DJ gig at a gorgeous venue on the Olentangy River, plans for an upcoming charity golf outing at Mohawk, and hilariously awkward public bathroom encounters. The hosts' willingness to share embarrassing childhood tales creates an atmosphere of relatability despite the outrageous nature of some anecdotes.
Whether you're a long-time listener or first-time discoverer of this unapologetically authentic podcast, this episode delivers the perfect blend of humor, honesty, and unexpected insights that will have you coming back for more. Subscribe now and join us for next week's adventures!
Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)!
'Beavis and Butt-head' Cover art created by Joe Crawford
Show more best episodes

Show more best episodes
FAQ
How many episodes does It's Everyday with John and Jay have?
It's Everyday with John and Jay currently has 174 episodes available.
What topics does It's Everyday with John and Jay cover?
The podcast is about Pop Culture, Funny, Improv, Comedy, Podcasts, Video Games, Tv Reviews, Nostalgia and Tv & Film.
What is the most popular episode on It's Everyday with John and Jay?
The episode title 'Episode 40: The Addams Family (1991)..They're Creepy and They're Kooky.' is the most popular.
What is the average episode length on It's Everyday with John and Jay?
The average episode length on It's Everyday with John and Jay is 68 minutes.
How often are episodes of It's Everyday with John and Jay released?
Episodes of It's Everyday with John and Jay are typically released every 7 days.
When was the first episode of It's Everyday with John and Jay?
The first episode of It's Everyday with John and Jay was released on Jan 30, 2022.
Show more FAQ

Show more FAQ