In The Nick Of Crime

In the Nick of Crime

1 Creator

A podcast for true crime and spooky times. Co-hosts Courtney and Michelle. Email your story & case suggestions to [email protected]

#49 in the Top 100 Indie true crime All time chart

...more

36 Listeners

11 Comments

All episodes

Best episodes

Top 10 In The Nick Of Crime Episodes

Goodpods has curated a list of the 10 best In The Nick Of Crime episodes, ranked by the number of listens and likes each episode have garnered from our listeners. If you are listening to In The Nick Of Crime for the first time, there's no better place to start than with one of these standout episodes. If you are a fan of the show, vote for your favorite In The Nick Of Crime episode by adding your comments to the episode page.

Scoops and Lore 8 - Sleepy Slaughterhouse

In The Nick Of Crime

10/13/22 • 55 min

Happy Thursday, creeps and freaks! We have our 8th installment of Scoops and Lore for you. Courtney brings us through the legend of Sleep Hollow and Michelle shares ghost tales of Slaughterhouse Canyon. This one is bound to make you laugh, and wildly uncomfortable all at the same time! Thank you as always for listening! All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected] Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page. Source material for this episode: https://mythus.fandom.com/wiki/Headless_Horseman https://www.history.com/news/legend-sleepy-hollow-headless-horseman https://www.grunge.com/215250/the-legend-of-the-headless-horseman-explained/ https://puzzleboxhorror.com/the-ghosts-of-slaughterhouse-canyon/ https://medium.com/@juleana/slaughterhouse-canyon-acdaee28cd0b - photo credit for social media posts

10 Listeners

Episode 22 - Ronald Clark O'Bryan "The Candy Man"

In The Nick Of Crime

10/11/22 • 61 min

Have you ever felt the need to check your children's Halloween candy before they eat any of it? Chances are, it's because of this absolute piece of human garbage. This week, Michelle takes us through the horrendous story of Ronald Clark O'Bryan, who became know as "The Candy Man" and also, the man who ruined Halloween. Evil doesn't even begin to cover this one.

Please be advised that this story does discuss the death of a child.

Thank you as always for listening!

All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
The trailer you heard at the beginning of the episode is from our friend, Aolani, from Stories from the Mortuary podcast! Follow her, subscribe, rate and review her amazing podcast! linktr.ee/mortuarystories
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode:

https://people.com/crime/2-people-arrested-search-for-missing-child-discovery-of-human-remains/
https://www.aetv.com/real-crime/the-man-who-killed-halloween
https://murderpedia.org/male.O/o1/obryan-ronald-clark.htm
https://www.chron.com/news/slideshow/Ronald-Clark-O-Bryan-96674.php

10 Listeners

Scoops and Lore 7 - Stairway to Hell or Wonderland?

In The Nick Of Crime

09/29/22 • 65 min

Happy Thursday, creeps and freaks! We have reached our seventh installment of Scoops and Lore, and this one is a wild ride! Courtney may have found the location of a stairway that leads to Hell. And Michelle discusses the real people and stories behind Lewis Carroll's Through the Looking Glass as well as Disney's original animated Alice in Wonderland.

Thank you as always for listening!

All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode:

https://original.newsbreak.com/@evie-m-561146/2191352110306-apparently-there-s-a-gateway-to-hell-in-tagus-north-dakota
https://thoughtcatalog.com/kara-nesvig/2015/10/creepy-history-the-stairway-to-hell-in-tagus-north-dakota/
https://britishheritage.com/travel/real-story-alice-wonderland
https://www.roomtogrow.co.uk/blog/alice-wonderland-childrens-book/
https://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2012/01/lewis-carroll-201201

9 Listeners

Scoops and Lore 10 - Get in B*tches, We're Going Hagging

In The Nick Of Crime

11/17/22 • 52 min

Happy Thursday, creeps and freaks! We have a particularly goofy and ridiculous installment of Scoops and Lore for you today! Courtney introduces us to "hagging" while Michelle takes us through the creepy and sordid past of Tasmania's Port Aurthur.

Thank you as always for listening!

All things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Follow us on Twitter: @NickofCrime
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode:

8 Listeners

1 Comment

Episode 18 - Kendrick Johnson

In The Nick Of Crime

09/13/22 • 79 min

Hey creeps and freaks! This week, we are bringing you the incredibly sad and unfathomable story of Kendrick Johnson. Kendrick was a 17 year old high school student in Valdosta, Georgia, who mysteriously died in what authorities call a weird, tragic accident. But many think that this story is not what it seems, us included.

We would love to hear your thoughts on this case after you have listened and reviewed our source material.

Thank you as always for listening!

The trailer you heard at the beginning of the episode is from Brad and Denise with Worlds True Crime podcast! Go listen, subscribe to and rate their amazing show! linktr.ee/WorldsTrueCrime
All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source Material for the episode:

https://people.com/crime/woman-who-was-killed-in-calif-street-identified-father-says-he-pleaded-with-her-to-stay-away-from-suspect/
https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/26/us/kendrick-johnson-death-second-investigation-no-charges/index.html
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/investigation-georgia-teen-found-dead-gym-mat-closed-charges-rcna13868
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/georgia-sheriff-offers-500k-money-case-teen-found-dead-gym-mat-rcna14377
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/27/us/kendrick-johnson-georgia-investigation.html
https://crimejunkiepodcast.com/mysterious-death-kendrick-johnson/
https://www.npr.org/2021/03/10/975729899/probe-reopened-in-death-of-kendrick-johnson-georgia-teen-found-in-rolled-up-gym
https://allthatsinteresting.com/kendrick-johnson
16 - page synopsis of the investigation released by Lowndes County Sheriff, Ashley Paulk: https://bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com/valdostadailytimes.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/1/88/18846c0a-7edf-11ec-ae1d-ebc42ddb8a25/61f1a2c7b46f3.pdf.pdf

8 Listeners

Bonus Episode - Maura Murray (originally on Patreon)

In The Nick Of Crime

11/08/22 • 35 min

Happy Tuesday, creeps and freaks! We took a much needed break from recording last week, so we don't have a new episode to drop. We didn't want to leave you all hanging, however, so we are giving you an episode that was previously released to our Patreon only. In this episode, Courtney brings you the unsolved case of the disappearance of Maura Murray. Please check out the page dedicated to finding her and solving her case linked here: https://www.mauramurraymissing.org Thank you as always for listening! All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast Follow us on Twitter: @NickofCrime Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected] Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page. Source material for this episode: https://the-line-up.com/disappearance-of-maura-murray-case

8 Listeners

Episode 21 - The Slender Man Attack

In The Nick Of Crime

10/04/22 • 54 min

In this week's episode, Courtney discusses the 2014 attack of Payton Leutner, also known as the Slender Man attack. Spoiler alert - this one is a survivor story! And Payton's story is truly remarkable. Please note that this episode discusses mental illness and violence against children.

We also wanted to add that this week's episode doesn't contain a current true crime event (weekly f***ery). We had discussed one when we recorded the episode, but after we finished recording, family members of the victim we discussed expressed their desire for privacy and for the case to stop being covered while they process (understandably so). With that in mind, we decided to cut the segment from the episode. We understand that by covering current events, things like this can come up, but we never want to go against the wishes of those impacted the most.

Thank you as always for listening!

All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode:

7 Listeners

1 Comment

Scoops and Lore 9 - Spooktastic

In The Nick Of Crime

10/27/22 • 60 min

Happy Thursday, creeps and freaks! We apologize for this episode going out a bit late. We had some technical difficulties - there is one portion of the episode that we had to re-record, so the audio is off. But it's only for a short bit of time. But this week, we're bringing you a spooky smorgasbord if you will. Courtney takes us through the tale of the "Cora tree" of North Carolina and Michelle talks about the lore of "lost episodes". Plus, we have another listener story submitted by our lovely friend Katie with Malice and Mocktails! This episode has a bit of everything, and we hope you enjoy!

Thank you as always for listening!

If you want to watch some fan-made, absolutely creepy and even terrifying "lost episodes" - here is a YouTube video to check out! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJmSTWqtmUk
All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Follow us on Twitter: @NickofCrime
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode:

https://islandfreepress.org/hatteras-island-features/the-cora-tree-a-halloween-worthy-local-legend-or-a-link-to-the-lost-colony/
https://www.creepypasta.com/seinfeld-lost-episode/
https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Category:Lost_Episodes
https://creepypasta-land.fandom.com/wiki/Category:%22Lost_Episodes%22

7 Listeners

Episode 23 - The Halloween House of Horrors

In The Nick Of Crime

10/18/22 • 45 min

In the second week of our Halloween horror series, Courtney covers the case of the 2010 Liske/Griffin family murders. On Halloween of 2010, BJ Liske did the unthinkable, creating a scene that would be described as a real-life horror story.

Thank you as always for listening!

All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Follow us on Twitter: @NickofCrime
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode:

7 Listeners

Episode 25 - Halloween Injustices

In The Nick Of Crime

11/01/22 • 74 min

Hey creeps and freaks. We have a pretty tough episode all around this week. Courtney discusses the senseless murders of Sister Tadea Benz and Narne Box Bryson, as well as the subsequent execution of Johnny Frank Garrett. We have many opinions on what happened (which is very evident in the episode), and we hope you will weigh in on yours. Please be advised that this case discusses rape and violence against children. There is also an abundance of spicy language. We were very emotionally charged this episode!

Thank you as always for listening!

The trailer you heard at the beginning of this episode is from our lovely friends Beth and Bailey with True Crime BnB. Please go subscribe, rate and review their podcast! https://linktr.ee/truecrimebnb
All of the things In the Nick of Crime live here: linktr.ee/nickofcrimepod
Follow us on Instagram: @NickofCrimePodcast
Follow us on TikTok: @InTheNickOfCrimePodcast
Follow us on Twitter: @NickofCrime
Email us your stories or case suggestions to: [email protected]
Become a Patron! https://www.patreon.com/IntheNickofCrime - Get ad-free and early episodes, as well as a bonus episode every month! We also post extended show notes, pictures and materials for the public from this page.

Source material for this episode: