Log in

goodpods headphones icon

To access all our features

Open the Goodpods app
Close icon
headphones
Illegitimate Scholar

Illegitimate Scholar

Samuel Urban

Our culture is in crisis and I don’t trust woke universities and authoritarian governments to give us the solution. I examine modern culture through history and anthropology, as well as other sources like indigenous knowledge and common sense. This is a show for those who love academics but hate academia, and want to learn about social studies without the constraining limits of woke universities. Reach me on Discord, https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj and other sites: https://pod.link/1650280020, If you have any thoughts you'd like to share please email me: [email protected]

bookmark
Share icon

All episodes

Best episodes

Top 10 Illegitimate Scholar Episodes

Goodpods has curated a list of the 10 best Illegitimate Scholar episodes, ranked by the number of listens and likes each episode have garnered from our listeners. If you are listening to Illegitimate Scholar for the first time, there's no better place to start than with one of these standout episodes. If you are a fan of the show, vote for your favorite Illegitimate Scholar episode by adding your comments to the episode page.

Illegitimate Scholar - 049 - Cultural Diffusion

049 - Cultural Diffusion

Illegitimate Scholar

play

12/17/23 • 14 min

I discuss cultural diffusion, how how cultures spread over time.
This is important to understanding why cultures change over time and recognize it when you see it historically or contemporarily.
We discuss forced, direct, and indirect diffusion. These are the Mechanisms with which cultural diffusion happens.
I then break down cultural diffusion to the five types, expansion diffusion, relocation diffusion, hierarchical diffusion, contagious diffusion, Stimulus Diffusion.

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - IS on the Good Ole Boyz Podcast: Gods, Blood, and Wheels
play

08/22/23 • 137 min

My favorite fellow podcasters and I sat down for the second time to discuss the arguments of Jared Diamond "Guns, Germs, and Steel, other topics in Anthropology, and discussion of the origin of the wheel and the Indo-Aryans.
Listen to their show here:
https://open.spotify.com/show/0PKWQJTzq9RqoUQrEAHshl?si=3ce3e593ab464d9d
Six Spots available for $2/ month right now:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar
Discord:

https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj

Audio Podcast:

https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:

https://twitter.com/ill_scholar

Books and Audible:

Audible AUDIOBOOKS, free trial:

https://amzn.to/3TJOARA"American Nations" - Cultural history of the US focused on distinct cultural areas and their affects. Link: https://amzn.to/3P6lTwn
The three big anthropology books I recommend :
"Guns, Germs and Steel" - https://amzn.to/3qI271S
"Dawn of Everything" Graeber/Wengrow - culturally left wing big (pop) anthropology/history book. Good for diversity of thought, many good references here. - https://amzn.to/47Fl6uH
"Sapiens" - Globalist/WEF but a decent take to understand their position. -https://amzn.to/47FEW95
Other reccomendations:
"The Korean War" -Bruce Cummings, history of colonization of Korea and the context of the nationalist/communist wars of East Asia. - https://amzn.to/3smlLB3
"Oracle Bones" - Book on China from a journalist's perspective in the 90s, exceptional and if people want to read one book on China I recommend this one. - https://amzn.to/3YOOfzE
"1491" - Mann. So much of what we know about Native Americans is tainted by influence of Europeans (by the time Europeans were writing a lot of stuff down, especially in English 200 years had passed since first contact and almost everyone was dead and the cultures were irrevocably changed, even if they didn't meet Europeans yet). The lost history of pre-Columbian western hemisphere is a glimpse into so many unique cultures that challenge our assumptions of human nature as well as history. - https://amzn.to/45luIsM

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchase

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - ISL 006 - w/ Brad Pearce

ISL 006 - w/ Brad Pearce

Illegitimate Scholar

play

07/21/23 • 94 min

This is ISL, Illegitimate Scholar live, news current events discussed by the Illegitimate Scholar. Live recording is done every Thursday night, 8pm eastern
Today I am joined by Brad Pearce.
Substack: https://www.thewaywardrabbler.com/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/waywardrabbler?lang=en

Discord:

https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj

Audio Podcast:

https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:

https://twitter.com/ill_scholar

  1. Surrogate claims gay dads told her to terminate pregnancy at 24 weeks on finding out she had aggressive cancer and barred her from having baby prematurely or putting it up for adoption because 'they didn't want their DNA out there'

    1. Right over your own body?
    2. Abortion is so accepted these guys can make that decision for her?
    3. Woman has cancer, pregnant and these gay dudes threatening her with a lawsuit and making her kill her child
      1. You get two murder charges if you kill a pregnant woman
  2. The Missouri v. Biden Injunction is a Rare Win for Freedom

  3. A New War On Drug Terror

  4. The BRICs Go For Gold

    1. Loss of reserve currency
    2. US pushing rivals together
  5. CMT pulls Jason Aldean video: What to know about 'Try That In A Small Town' controversy

    1. Burn down cities
    2. Attack people
    3. Disparage white people constantly
    4. Media, news and Hollywood supports the politics of the left
      1. Made excuses for mass violence, even killing
      2. Left mocks people like Ashli Babbet killed, unarmed
    5. The last bastions of conservatism in life are now being attacked
      1. Country Music
    6. Examples of promotion of violence on the other side get context. Jason Aldean doesn’t
      1. Four quotes. All while real violence was happening
      2. AFP oldest news service
    7. gARBAGE, PANDERING
  6. Hate speech posted on economics website is traced to some leading universities, research finds

    1. Study exempt from IRB
    2. These people feel they can’t say THEIR TRUTH, THEIR LIVED EXPERIENCE without fear of reprisal.
      1. Some of this stuff is fully racist, and I don’t think it’s cool
        1. But so is a lot of stuff these universities do, and the bribes they take
  7. What we know about Travis King, the U.S. soldier who crossed into North Korea

    1. This kid embarrassed the army
    2. LEGEND
    3. He knew he screwed his life up
      1. Lost his honor
      2. Embarassed his country family
      3. Treated like crap
    4. THIS IS HIS CHANCE AT A RESTART
      1. MOST OF US COULD ONLY DREAM
    5. HE DEFECTED TO NK
  8. Iraq expels Sweden ambassador, embassy stormed over Quran burning

    1. The beliefs of Islamic nations are incompatible with western liberalism
      1. People need to admit that
    2. Chaos

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 033 - Caffeine and Capitalism: A Culture's Choice of Drug
play

05/20/23 • 19 min

Indigenous cultures often have hallucinogenic traditions, from Meso-America, to Africa, the Pacific, and indigenous Europe. The United States, Spain, and Japan, just as diverse, all drink similar amounts of coffee while being very different cultures. Why do these cultures that differ so much share these traits, and what do these, and the use of other drugs tell us about the values and customs of a culture?

I’m Sam and this is the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast. The weekly cultural anthropology and history podcast that tries to make sense of our senseless world through indigenous and historical examples, academic methods in social science, and a perspective not limited by the crushing restrictions that come with traditional academia and public schools.
Today we are going to find out the similarities in a few indigenous hallucinogenic traditions, and why these similar traditions thrived in these very different cultures. Then, what makes alcohol tied to settled life. What makes alcohol give way to caffeine as the main drug of the west, and what are the consequences of this shift are. Finally, what the drugs of the last few decades have to say about the state of our modern culture.

Discord:

https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj

Audio Podcast:

https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:

https://twitter.com/ill_scholar

BOOKS

“The Horse, the Wheel, and Language”::

https://amzn.to/3BK7gsg

“Uncommon Ground: The History of Coffee and how it changed the world

https://amzn.to/43dxFtZ

Audible AUDIOBOOKS, free trial: https://amzn.to/3TJOARA

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
#podcast #history #anthropology #culture #socialanthropology #culturalanthropology #politicalscience #geopolitics #indigenous #politics #libertarian #liberty

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 068 - American Indian Experience: Past, Present, & Future
play

09/22/24 • 86 min

Exploring Native American Heritage, cultural preservation, and Mystical Legends
Twitter: https://x.com/Bugimus
In Episode 63 of the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast I am joined by Bugs Mitchell, member of the Chippewa tribe in Wisconsin's Bad River Band, to explore Native American heritage and identity. Bugs discusses reconnecting with his tribe, reclaiming his Native American name, and the cultural significance of hair. Delve into the challenges and processes of preserving Ojibwe traditions, the legal struggles tribes face in reclaiming their land. We also touch on the lore of Skinwalker Ranch, tribal unity, and the portrayal of Native Americans in media. This episode offers vital insights into the rich traditions, contemporary challenges, and true essence of Native American cultures.
00:00 IS Bugs Mitchell
00:34 Introduction to Bugs Mitchell and His Heritage
01:16 Tribal Names and Lineage
02:25 Reconnecting with the Tribe
03:13 Application Process and Tribal Membership
07:47 Cultural Heritage and Bigfoot Connection
10:07 Tribal Government and Ceremonies
18:15 Language Preservation and Education
23:01 Hair and Personal Identity
30:47 Representation in Media and Sports
42:11 Debating Cultural Representation
43:16 The Land O'Lakes Controversy
45:03 Exploring Native American Religions
52:46 The Noble Savage Myth
01:02:15 Modern Native American Issues
01:22:39 Tribal Government and Legal Challenges
01:24:32 Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 053 - American Expat on the Asian Steppe
play

02/26/24 • 80 min

I, Samuel Urban, the Illegitimate Scholar talk to Rogue Philosopher, an American who emigrated from New Jersey to Central Asia. The discussions center around his experiences of the distinct nomadic traditions, local business dynamics, religious beliefs, and unique practices like bride kidnapping, and the outlook on life in Kyrgyzstan. Rogue Philosopher teaches Philosophy there and wants to get closer to Traditional Life that he sees as gone in the United States. We talk about Marriage Practies, dating, the genetics and culture of the people there and their nomadic history. We talk about the viability of being a Passport Bro in Central Asia, specifically Kyrgyzstan

0:00 053 Central Asian

00:17 Intro

00:46 Rogue Philosophy

02:50 Reject Modernity

03:49 Literature Professor

05:25 Children in Kyrgyzstan

07:06 Kyrgyz vs Western Logic

10:23 Take the Nomad Pill

18:28 Trouble with the Law

22:09 History/Genetics

26:26 Dating/Marriage

41:02 Religion

49:51 Why YOU should go to Central Asia

53:07 Pop Culture/Social Media

56:53 Assimilating in Central Asia

01:02:42 Eating Horse

01:04:31 Bean Selling Heiress

01:13:27 Future of Kyrgyzstan

01:18:56 Closing Thoughts

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 040 - Practical Benefits of Religion
play

08/22/23 • 37 min

  1. Today, how do religions form and evolve based on new and changing circumstances? What do they practically provide adherents and cultures?
    1. How do religious beliefs reflect their environment?
      1. Human
      2. Physical
      3. Need of the society
    2. What conditions lead to a new religious practice and the decline of old?
      1. Examples
      2. Syncretic Religions and their extreme
    3. Then some specific examples of religions applied practically

Six Spots available for $2/ month right now:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar
Discord:

https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj

Audio Podcast:

https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:

https://twitter.com/ill_scholar

Books and Audible:

Audible AUDIOBOOKS, free trial:

https://amzn.to/3TJOARA"American Nations" - Cultural history of the US focused on distinct cultural areas and their affects. Link: https://amzn.to/3P6lTwn
The three big anthropology books I recommend :
"Guns, Germs and Steel" - https://amzn.to/3qI271S
"Dawn of Everything" Graeber/Wengrow - culturally left wing big (pop) anthropology/history book. Good for diversity of thought, many good references here. - https://amzn.to/47Fl6uH
"Sapiens" - Globalist/WEF but a decent take to understand their position. -https://amzn.to/47FEW95
Other reccomendations:
"The Korean War" -Bruce Cummings, history of colonization of Korea and the context of the nationalist/communist wars of East Asia. - https://amzn.to/3smlLB3
"Oracle Bones" - Book on China from a journalist's perspective in the 90s, exceptional and if people want to read one book on China I recommend this one. - https://amzn.to/3YOOfzE
"1491" - Mann. So much of what we know about Native Americans is tainted by influence of Europeans (by the time Europeans were writing a lot of stuff down, especially in English 200 years had passed since first contact and almost everyone was dead and the cultures were irrevocably changed, even if they didn't meet Europeans yet). The lost history of pre-Columbian western hemisphere is a glimpse into so many unique cultures that challenge our assumptions of human nature as well as history. - https://amzn.to/45luIsM

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchase

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 037 - Religion is Not Real

037 - Religion is Not Real

Illegitimate Scholar

play

07/23/23 • 29 min

Discord:

https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj

Audio Podcast:

https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:

https://twitter.com/ill_scholar

Welcome to the Illegitimate Scholar podcast, the weekly cultural anthropology podcast that explores our senseless world through indigenous and historical examples, academic methods, and social science. In this episode, the host, Sam, delves into the Anthropology of Religion, seeking to understand the various perspectives on religion from an academic, indigenous, and historical standpoint.

Sam begins by clarifying that everyone worships something, and the only choice we have is what to worship. He dismisses atheism as a "fake" concept and declares his intention to approach the topic of religion without bias or offense. Sam shares his religious background, explaining that he was raised in a Catholic family, but has since been exposed to various religious beliefs, including Unitarianism, Islam, Judaism, and Buddhism. He expresses interest in understanding religion from a lens of eternal truth and cultural context.

The podcast then explores different definitions of religion provided by renowned anthropologists. Emile Durkheim defines religion as a unified system of beliefs and practices related to sacred things, forming a moral community. Clifford Geertz views religion as a system of symbols that shape powerful and long-lasting moods and motivations. Melford Spiro describes religion as an institution involving culturally patterned interactions with culturally postulated superhuman beings.

Sam emphasizes that religion is a cultural construct and becomes problematic when people attempt to rigidly define it or deny its existence. He argues that religion is an essential aspect of human life, whether it involves traditional faith or secular beliefs.

Throughout the series, Sam promises to explore various religious examples and cultural perspectives, using ethnographies and audience suggestions. He encourages listeners to join the conversation on the Discord platform and participate in enriching discussions.

Join Sam on the Illegitimate Scholar podcast to gain insights into the complex and diverse nature of religion across different cultures and historical contexts. (AI written for keywords)

Discord:

https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj

Audio Podcast:

https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:

https://twitter.com/ill_scholar

#podcast #religion #history #anthropology #illegitimatescholar #culturalanthropology #socioculturalanthropology #anthropologyofreligion #christianity #islam #judaism #spirituality #politicalscience #socialscience #socialstudies #libertarian #libertarianpodcasts #podcasts #Americanculture #culture #geopolitics #historypodcasts #historyfacts #historical #socialconstructs

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 015 - Does Voting Matter?

015 - Does Voting Matter?

Illegitimate Scholar

play

12/24/22 • 19 min

Does voting work? How would we know? What is the result of voting? Who benefits? Who gets their policies put in place?What is the purpose of voting and what other metrics besides some loser politician getting elected can we use to tell if it is working? I use math (statistics) to prove that only what the rich want is put into place as policy. This happens as the rich take hold of social institutions. This is shown by a 2014 Princeton Study. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Audible AUDIOBOOKS, free trial:
https://amzn.to/3TJOARA
Reach me on Discord,
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020Subscribe:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw?sub_confirmation=1
#podcast #socioeconomics #sociology #voting #democracy #democracyisbroken #voting #vote #republic #republican #politics #culture #videopodcast #history #anthropology #culturalanthropology #historyfacts #historical #antiwoke #woke #illegitimatescholar #libertarian #freedom #cultural #commentary #conservative #socialstudies #socialscience

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode
Illegitimate Scholar - 047 - Fat Acceptance is Unnacceptable
play

11/05/23 • 34 min

I discuss the fat acceptance movement, it's history and origins, and current state. I describe connections to other ideologies. I discuss the result of a culture that allows and promotes people to live in a state of unhealthiness. I talk about a few things from Michael Pollan's book, "In Defense of Food". We discuss food cultures and the issues of our own culture being based on industrial production of food and not on producing food.

Discord:
https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj
Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar

Audio Podcast:
https://pod.link/1650280020

Twitter.com:
https://twitter.com/ill_scholar
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

bookmark
plus icon
share episode

Show more best episodes

Toggle view more icon

FAQ

How many episodes does Illegitimate Scholar have?

Illegitimate Scholar currently has 97 episodes available.

What topics does Illegitimate Scholar cover?

The podcast is about Culture, Society & Culture, History, Podcasts, Gender, Anthropology and Race.

What is the most popular episode on Illegitimate Scholar?

The episode title 'IS Geopolitics: Haiti's Civil War w/ Brad Pearce' is the most popular.

What is the average episode length on Illegitimate Scholar?

The average episode length on Illegitimate Scholar is 60 minutes.

How often are episodes of Illegitimate Scholar released?

Episodes of Illegitimate Scholar are typically released every 6 days, 22 hours.

When was the first episode of Illegitimate Scholar?

The first episode of Illegitimate Scholar was released on Oct 17, 2022.

Show more FAQ

Toggle view more icon

Comments