Episode 15: Depicting War in Art and Music: Of Fallen Heroes and Epic Battles

Description

In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Emily Maeda and Tim McIntosh shift their focus to the depiction of war in art and music. They explore how Beethoven’s Eroica Symphony, Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture, and iconic paintings like Napoleon Crossing the Alps and Washington Crossing the Delaware capture the complexities of heroism, leadership, and the costs of war. The conversation unpacks how the Enlightenment and Romantic eras shaped these artistic works and their depictions of war. Emily’s hot take questions whether liberal democracies can balance the need for heroic figures with their commitment to equality and the rule of law.

Show Guide

00:00 Opening Remarks and the Challenge of Depicting War in Art

04:15 The Enlightenment and the Absence of War Literature in the 18th Century

09:24 Beethoven’s Eroica: From Dedication to Disillusionment

18:09 Napoleon in Art: David’s Napoleon Crossing the Alps

27:56 Washington as the Anti-Napoleon: Washington Crossing the Delaware

34:11 Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture: A Celebration of Russian Resilience

42:00 Goya’s The Third of May: The Brutality of War on the Common Man

50:10 Emily’s Hot Take: The Heroic Ideal and Liberal Democracies

55:30 Closing Remarks and Next Episode Preview

Key Topics & Takeaways

• Beethoven’s Disillusionment with Napoleon: The Eroica Symphony began as a tribute to Napoleon’s leadership but became a reflection of disillusionment after Napoleon declared himself emperor.
• Napoleon vs. Washington in Art: Jacques-Louis David’s Napoleon Crossing the Alps glorifies a solitary and triumphant figure, while Leutze’s Washington Crossing the Delaware emphasizes collective effort and duty.
• Tchaikovsky’s Musical Nationalism: The 1812 Overture uses motifs like the French national anthem and a Russian hymn to narrate Napoleon’s failed invasion of Russia.
• The Brutality of War: Goya’s The Third of May offers a harrowing depiction of the human cost of war, contrasting with more glorified portrayals.
• Heroism in Liberal Democracies: Emily argues that modern democratic values complicate the creation of heroic figures, as equality and rule of law clash with the concept of larger-than-life leaders.

Questions & Discussion

• How does Beethoven’s Eroica reflect the shift from Enlightenment ideals to Romantic individualism?
  Analyze how Beethoven’s relationship with Napoleon influenced the symphony’s themes of heroism and disillusionment.
• What are the differences between Napoleon and Washington in art?
  Explore how their depictions serve distinct political and cultural narratives.
• How does Tchaikovsky musically convey the story of Napoleon’s defeat in Russia?
  Discuss the use of nationalistic and religious motifs in the 1812 Overture.
• What does Goya’s The Third of May reveal about the personal toll of war?
  Consider how the painting portrays the contrast between power and vulnerability.
• Can liberal democracies produce heroic figures?
  Reflect on the tension between democratic values and the desire for inspiring leaders.

Suggested Viewing & Listening

• Beethoven’s Eroica Symphony
• Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture
• Jacques-Louis David’s Napoleon Crossing the Alps
• Emanuel Leutze’s Washington Crossing the Delaware
• Francisco Goya’s The Third of May 1808
• The Battle of Borodino painting