
Episode 31-(S2-Ep 14)-"To Be Or Not To Be"
Explicit content warning
02/25/22 • 132 min
1 Listener
Welcome Back Creek Talkers!
This week we're dealing with an ignorant teacher, a very personal poem and a much-deserved DNA facial. And Jen is now starring in her own spin-off about a girl dating a boy who is definitely NOT losing his Religion.
We're breaking down one of the most talked about and most important episodes of Dawson's Creek --Season 2, Episode 14, titled, "To Be or Not to Be." aka: Jack's Coming Out Story.
Jack (Kerr Smith) and Pacey (Joshua Jackson) are in Mr. Peterson's poetry class. He's given them an assignment to write a poem about what they know. Struggling with this concept, Jack decides to write about the first thing he sees when he closes his eyes.
When Peterson forces Jack to read his poem out loud to his class, Pacey defends his new friend by making some life choices even we don't think we'd make. Especially not at 16 years old.
Now Pacey has to own up to the consequences or be suspended. Which leads to a lot of tension between him and Andie (Meredith Monroe).
Meanwhile, Joey (Katie Holmes) runs to Dawson (James Van Der Beek) for advice when rumors of Jack's poem make the rounds in Capeside.
In a totally different show, Jen (Michelle Williams) is getting closer to her new beau Tyson (Eddie Mills). After much persistence, Ty shows Jen a side of himself that his Religion would most definitely not approve of.
We also discuss our drunken nights out, denial, and really wanting a Wendy's Frosty. So, grab some paper and a pen and start brainstorming a very personal poem, because we're about to be outed against our will by the most hated teacher in Capeside! Join us for "To Be or Not to Be."
We hope you enjoy this episode and have a great weekend, Creek Talkers!
**RATE & REVIEW US on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher or wherever you listen to podcasts!
**FOLLOW US on INSTAGRAM @CreekTalkPodcast
**FOLLOW US on TWITTER @CreekTalkPod
**FOLLOW Jayme's #Bookstagram @Jaylynn_Booklover
**FOLLOW Justin Michael - YouTube #TarotTube
**Visit our LinkTree:
https://linktr.ee/CreekTalkPodcast
**WE WANNA HEAR FROM YOU!!--Send us an Email @ [email protected]
**Original Theme Song Written & Performed by Justin Michael
**Original Lyrics Written by Stephen Gavis & Jayme Whitehead
#creektalkpodcast #dawsonscreek #podcasters #jamesvanderbeek #katieholmes #michellewilliams #joshuajackson #kerrsmith #meredithmonroe #busyphillips #marymargarethumes #johnwesleyshipp #marybethpiel #ninarepeta #kevinwilliamson #dawsonleery #joeypotter #jenlindley #paceywitter #jackmcphee #andiemcphee #audreyliddell #the90s #90stv #thewb #nostalgia #teendrama #youngamericans #glorydays #wolflake #wasteland #buffythevampireslayer #buffy #btvs #sarahmichellegellar #alysonhannigan #nicholasbrendan #charismacarpenter #davidboreanaz #anthonystewarthead #jamesmarsters #julietlandau #sethgreen #robiascott #buffysummers #willowrosenberg #xanderharris #cordeliachase #rupertgiles #angel #spike #drusilla #oz #jennycalendar #hellmouth #sunnydale #horror #comedy #drama #slayer #vampires #katebosworth #iansomerhalder #markfamiglietti #rodneyscott #katemoennig #edquinn #mattczuchry #charliehunnam #steveantin #eddiecahill #poppymontgomery #jayrferguson #emilyvancamp #bencrowley #amystewart #theresarussell #francesfisher #adamscott#marisacoughlan #sashaalexander #eddiemills #rebeccagayheart #bradrowe #danmontgomeryjr #jeffreydsams #dawnieparker #samprice #vandy #jessepresser #russellbaskind #tyswindell #vincelewis
Welcome Back Creek Talkers!
This week we're dealing with an ignorant teacher, a very personal poem and a much-deserved DNA facial. And Jen is now starring in her own spin-off about a girl dating a boy who is definitely NOT losing his Religion.
We're breaking down one of the most talked about and most important episodes of Dawson's Creek --Season 2, Episode 14, titled, "To Be or Not to Be." aka: Jack's Coming Out Story.
Jack (Kerr Smith) and Pacey (Joshua Jackson) are in Mr. Peterson's poetry class. He's given them an assignment to write a poem about what they know. Struggling with this concept, Jack decides to write about the first thing he sees when he closes his eyes.
When Peterson forces Jack to read his poem out loud to his class, Pacey defends his new friend by making some life choices even we don't think we'd make. Especially not at 16 years old.
Now Pacey has to own up to the consequences or be suspended. Which leads to a lot of tension between him and Andie (Meredith Monroe).
Meanwhile, Joey (Katie Holmes) runs to Dawson (James Van Der Beek) for advice when rumors of Jack's poem make the rounds in Capeside.
In a totally different show, Jen (Michelle Williams) is getting closer to her new beau Tyson (Eddie Mills). After much persistence, Ty shows Jen a side of himself that his Religion would most definitely not approve of.
We also discuss our drunken nights out, denial, and really wanting a Wendy's Frosty. So, grab some paper and a pen and start brainstorming a very personal poem, because we're about to be outed against our will by the most hated teacher in Capeside! Join us for "To Be or Not to Be."
We hope you enjoy this episode and have a great weekend, Creek Talkers!
**RATE & REVIEW US on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher or wherever you listen to podcasts!
**FOLLOW US on INSTAGRAM @CreekTalkPodcast
**FOLLOW US on TWITTER @CreekTalkPod
**FOLLOW Jayme's #Bookstagram @Jaylynn_Booklover
**FOLLOW Justin Michael - YouTube #TarotTube
**Visit our LinkTree:
https://linktr.ee/CreekTalkPodcast
**WE WANNA HEAR FROM YOU!!--Send us an Email @ [email protected]
**Original Theme Song Written & Performed by Justin Michael
**Original Lyrics Written by Stephen Gavis & Jayme Whitehead
#creektalkpodcast #dawsonscreek #podcasters #jamesvanderbeek #katieholmes #michellewilliams #joshuajackson #kerrsmith #meredithmonroe #busyphillips #marymargarethumes #johnwesleyshipp #marybethpiel #ninarepeta #kevinwilliamson #dawsonleery #joeypotter #jenlindley #paceywitter #jackmcphee #andiemcphee #audreyliddell #the90s #90stv #thewb #nostalgia #teendrama #youngamericans #glorydays #wolflake #wasteland #buffythevampireslayer #buffy #btvs #sarahmichellegellar #alysonhannigan #nicholasbrendan #charismacarpenter #davidboreanaz #anthonystewarthead #jamesmarsters #julietlandau #sethgreen #robiascott #buffysummers #willowrosenberg #xanderharris #cordeliachase #rupertgiles #angel #spike #drusilla #oz #jennycalendar #hellmouth #sunnydale #horror #comedy #drama #slayer #vampires #katebosworth #iansomerhalder #markfamiglietti #rodneyscott #katemoennig #edquinn #mattczuchry #charliehunnam #steveantin #eddiecahill #poppymontgomery #jayrferguson #emilyvancamp #bencrowley #amystewart #theresarussell #francesfisher #adamscott#marisacoughlan #sashaalexander #eddiemills #rebeccagayheart #bradrowe #danmontgomeryjr #jeffreydsams #dawnieparker #samprice #vandy #jessepresser #russellbaskind #tyswindell #vincelewis
Previous Episode

Episode 30-(S2-Ep 13)-"His Leading Lady"
Welcome Back Creek Talkers!!
This week we're filming a movie funded by the BOSTON FILM FESTIVAL! And it's starring Rachael Leigh Cook! Join us as we recap Season 2, Episode 13, "His Leading Lady."
Dawson (James Van Der Beek) and Joey (Katie Holmes) are trying to work on their friendship again. While volunteering on Dawson's new movie, Joey realizes that she may not be so ready to jump back into their Friday movie night ritual.
Jen (Michelle Williams) is introduced to a cute new boy named Tyson Hicks (Eddie Mills). After joining the film and flirting with each other all day, will Tyson be just the thing Jen is looking for? Or will this be a disaster of biblical proportions?
Pacey (Joshua Jackson) and Andie (Meredith Monroe) are going through some rough waters after Andie is taken off her prescription medication. Will this be the end for Capeside's cutest couple? Or will Pacey keep fighting for the woman he loves?
We also discuss first date etiquette and our international listeners! So, get camera ready and start memorizing your lines because this week, we're giving even the BIGGEST stars a run for their money! Join us for "His Leading Lady!"
**RATE & REVIEW US on iTunes, Spotify or wherever you listen to our podcast!
**FOLLOW US on INSTAGRAM @CreekTalkPodcast
**FOLLOW US on TWITTER @CreekTalkPod
**FOLLOW Jayme's #Bookstagram @Jaylynn_Booklover
**Visit our LinkTree:
https://linktr.ee/CreekTalkPodcast
**WE WANNA HEAR FROM YOU!!--Send Us an Email @
[email protected]
**Original Theme Song Written & Performed by Justin Michael
FOLLOW Justin Michael - YouTube
**Original Lyrics Written by Stephen Gavis & Jayme Whitehead
#creektalkpodcast #dawsonscreek #podcasters #jamesvanderbeek #katieholmes #michellewilliams #joshuajackson #kerrsmith #meredithmonroe #busyphillips #marymargarethumes #johnwesleyshipp #marybethpiel #ninarepeta #kevinwilliamson #dawsonleery #joeypotter #jenlindley #paceywitter #jackmcphee #andiemcphee #audreyliddell #the90s #90stv #thewb #nostalgia #teendrama #youngamericans #glorydays #wolflake #wasteland #buffythevampireslayer #buffy #btvs #sarahmichellegellar #alysonhannigan #nicholasbrendan #charismacarpenter #davidboreanaz #anthonystewarthead #jamesmarsters #julietlandau #sethgreen #robiascott #buffysummers #willowrosenberg #xanderharris #cordeliachase #rupertgiles #angel #spike #drusilla #oz #jennycalendar #hellmouth #sunnydale #horror #comedy #drama #slayer #vampires #katebosworth #iansomerhalder #markfamiglietti #rodneyscott #katemoennig #edquinn #mattczuchry #charliehunnam #steveantin #eddiecahill #poppymontgomery #jayrferguson #emilyvancamp #bencrowley #amystewart #theresarussell #francesfisher #adamscott#marisacoughlan #sashaalexander #eddiemills #rebeccagayheart #bradrowe #danmontgomeryjr #jeffreydsams #dawnieparker #samprice #vandy #jessepresser #russellbaskind #tyswindell #vincelewis
Next Episode

Episode 32-(S2-Ep 15)-"That Is the Question"
Welcome Back Creek Talkers!
This week we conclude Jack's "Coming Out" story arc with Season 2, Episode 15, titled "That Is the Question."
When Jack (Kerr Smith) and Andie's (Meredith Monroe) father suddenly shows up in Capeside, another family secret finally comes to light when Jack admits to everyone, including himself, that he's gay.
Joey (Katie Holmes) begins to feel insecure about herself after the rumor mill keeps spinning about Jack's sexuality. Meanwhile, she starts to get closer to Dawson (James Van Der Beek) again after realizing that maybe she really does need her old friend right now.
Pacey (Joshua Jackson) is back from his week-long suspension. While he's still not speaking to Andie since their last exchange, he has more important things on his mind--like his crusade to make an example out of Mr. Peterson.
Jen (Michelle Williams) sees another side of Ty (Eddie Mills) after he gives his unwanted opinion on Jack's sexuality.
Stephen discusses his own coming out story and Jayme is still down her rabbit hole of Asian Rom Coms. And we have more listener mail!! This might be a heavy topic this week, but we still know how to laugh and have fun. We hope you can join us as we break down this very important piece of episodic tv!
Have a great weekend, Creek Talkers!
**RATE & REVIEW US on iTunes, Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts!
Visit our LinkTree:
https://linktr.ee/CreekTalkPodcast
**FOLLOW US on INSTAGRAM @CreekTalkPodcast
**FOLLOW US on TWITTER @CreekTalkPod
**FOLLOW Jayme's #Bookstagram @Jaylynn_Booklover
**FOLLOW Justin Michael - YouTube #TarotTube
**WE WANNA HEAR FROM YOU!!--Send us an Email @ [email protected]
**Original Theme Song Written & Performed by Justin Michael
**Original Lyrics Written by Stephen Gavis & Jayme Whitehead
#creektalkpodcast #dawsonscreek #podcasters #jamesvanderbeek #katieholmes #michellewilliams #joshuajackson #kerrsmith #meredithmonroe #busyphillips #marymargarethumes #johnwesleyshipp #marybethpiel #ninarepeta #kevinwilliamson #dawsonleery #joeypotter #jenlindley #paceywitter #jackmcphee #andiemcphee #audreyliddell #the90s #90stv #thewb #nostalgia #teendrama #youngamericans #glorydays #wolflake #wasteland #buffythevampireslayer #buffy #btvs #sarahmichellegellar #alysonhannigan #nicholasbrendan #charismacarpenter #davidboreanaz #anthonystewarthead #jamesmarsters #julietlandau #sethgreen #robiascott #buffysummers #willowrosenberg #xanderharris #cordeliachase #rupertgiles #angel #spike #drusilla #oz #jennycalendar #hellmouth #sunnydale #horror #comedy #drama #slayer #vampires #katebosworth #iansomerhalder #markfamiglietti #rodneyscott #katemoennig #edquinn #mattczuchry #charliehunnam #steveantin #eddiecahill #poppymontgomery #jayrferguson #emilyvancamp #bencrowley #amystewart #theresarussell #francesfisher #adamscott#marisacoughlan #sashaalexander #eddiemills #rebeccagayheart #bradrowe #danmontgomeryjr #jeffreydsams #dawnieparker #samprice #vandy #jessepresser #russellbaskind #tyswindell #vincelewis
If you like this episode you’ll love
Episode Comments
Generate a badge
Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode
<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/creek-talk-podcast-a-buffy-and-dawsons-creek-recap-show-183622/episode-31-s2-ep-14-to-be-or-not-to-be-19671062"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to episode 31-(s2-ep 14)-"to be or not to be" on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>
Copy