Judges now want us to know they’re human. But maybe we’d be better off if we didn’t know.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Explicit content warning
05/07/19 • 39 min
5 Listeners
Against the Rules with Michael Lewis - Baby Judge School
Transcript Summary
In the podcast episode titled "Baby Judge School," Jeremy Fogel, a former judge, explores the challenges and changing dynamics faced by judges in the justice system. Fogel emphasizes the need for judges to possess empathy and people-smarts, as they navigate emotional divorce cases. He argues that the public's lack of understanding of judges' roles and the justice system is a growing concern. Fogel left his position on the bench to bridge this gap and encourages judges to break their silence and be more transparent about their work. The episode also explores the connection between emotions and fairness, highlighted through an experiment with capuchin monkeys. Additionally, the impact of transparency, biases, societal factors, and public scrutiny on judges' decisions is discussed, emphasizing the importance of judges' independence and the public's trust for a fair legal system. By listening to this episode, one gains insight into the challenges faced by judges and the need for a better understanding of their role in society.
Transcript
Pushkin. One of the cooler things that happened in the last few decades is that scientists have decided that emotions are worth studying, and they found new ways to study them, not just in people, also in animals. The guy who's taken the lead with the animals is a Dutch primatologist named Franz Dawal. You know, emotions are sort of taboo topic. They used to be, at least, and so most of the time we don't explicitly discuss them. We discussed the
Baby Judge School Top Questions Answered
How are emotions being studied by scientists?
Scientists are studying emotions, including those of animals, to gain a better understanding of their nature and impact.
Who is a leading researcher in studying animal emotions?
Dutch primatologist Franz Dawal is a leading researcher in the study of animal emotions.
How do animals display emotions like fairness and anger?
Animals, such as capuchin monkeys, have been observed displaying emotions like fairness and anger in experiments and observations.
What happened in the fairness study involving monkeys?
In the fairness study, monkeys were given cucumber slices, but when one monkey received a grape, it caused the other monkey to become upset, highlighting their sense of fairness.
Do emotions drive behavior in both animals and humans?
Yes, emotions, such as a sense of fairness, play a role in driving behavior in both animals and humans.
How has Uzbekistan worked to establish a fair legal system?
Uzbekistan has been working to establish a legal system that includes fairness and independence for judges, addressing the lack of transparency and potential for fear and injustice.
What role do judges' emotions and attitudes play in the justice system?
Judges' emotions and attitudes play a significant role in the justice system, impacting their decisions and interactions with the parties involved.
Why are judges being watched more closely in Uzbekistan and the United States?
Judges are being watched more closely in Uzbekistan and the United States, leading to changes in the system, as transparency and accountability are recognized as necessary for maintaining trust and fairness.
What did Judge Jeremy Fogel advocate for in relation to judges?
Judge Jeremy Fogel advocated for judges to break their silence, be more transparent in their work, and prioritize humility and humanity in their judgments.
What were some challenges faced by Judge Jeremy Fogel during his career?
Judge Jeremy Fogel noticed the challenges of staying humble and making difficult life-and-death decisions, highlighting the emotional and ethical dilemmas faced by judges.
How can judges cope with their emotions to make fair decisions?
Judges can learn self-reflection and develop tools to cope with their emotions to make fair decisions, which is the essence of the "Baby Judge School" introduced to help new judges navigate the pressures and emotions of the job.
Show more Questions
Show more Questions
Generate a badge
Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode
<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/against-the-rules-with-michael-lewis-11531/baby-judge-school-10977079"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to baby judge school on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>
Copy