Indie only
Top 19 Mystery Podcasts
Jun 15, 2025
The Best Mystery Podcasts from millions of podcasts available on the Goodpods platform and ranked by listens, ratings, comments, subscriptions and shares.

314 Episodes
|
Avg Length 48m
|
Latest episode 1 day ago
Share

234 Episodes
|
Avg Length 15m
|
Latest episode 3 days ago
Share
HAUNTED: The Audio Drama tells the story of reclusive alcoholic writer James Hunter, bubbly enthusiastic podcaster Abigail Corbin and police officer Dan Cowell as they investigate strange and seemingly unexplainable phenomenon. Told in a classic serial format with episodes raging from suspenseful thrillers, to spine tingling horrors to laugh-out-loud comedies, HAUNTED: The Audio Drama is a horror adventure series that feels like Doctor Who crossed with The X Files.
Season 3 currently releasing!
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

662 Episodes
|
Avg Length 37m
|
Latest episode 5 days ago
Share

44 Episodes
|
Avg Length 25m
|
Latest episode 4 days ago
Share
An entire town... gone. Without a trace. No signs, no warnings. Just silence. This is the story of Cold Sparrow.
Twenty-four years ago, the peaceful town of Cold Sparrow became the center of one of the greatest unsolved mysteries in modern history. Every resident vanished. Among them, the enigmatic billionaire Benjamin Veers, whose strange ways made him an icon of intrigue. The town, once forgotten, now infamous. The questions? Endless. The answers? Nonexistent.
For over two decades, investigators have been left baffled—cults, kidnappings, disappearances—none have led them closer to the truth. But now, three celebrated private investigators—famous for bringing down one of the most dangerous cults in history—have been called upon to tackle this mystery. Known for taking on the cases no one else could solve, they’re determined to uncover what really happened in Cold Sparrow.
Yet, the deeper they dig, the darker the whispers become. Rumours swirl of something far more sinister than anyone ever imagined. Could the mystery of Cold Sparrow be tied to forces that reach far beyond our world? Could it be linked to something... infernal?
Some mysteries, once uncovered, may be better left untouched. Cold Sparrow: A town that disappeared... but something still lingers in the shadows.
The investigation begins... now.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Regular crime, thriller & mystery interviews, features and reviews. Flagship weekly show - IN PERSON WITH PAUL hosted by Paul Burke & seasonal series #OnTheSofaWithVictoria hosted by best selling thriller writer Victoria Selman. Also festival coverage, award ceremonies and magazine shows hosted by Paul with Victoria and Crime Time editor/Financial Times crime critic Barry Forshaw. The monthly Review Show, what's hot in crime fiction. Further information can be found at crimetime.fm
Semi-late night community radio broadcasts from a strange little town in the Crowsnest Pass, Alberta (aka, not just the middle of nowhere, but nowhere itself). Nothing ever happens here. Certainly nothing weird. Why would you even suggest that? Listen close. Don't wander off. It's a long way to get where you're going. Especially out here.

580 Episodes
|
Avg Length 70m
|
Latest episode 2 days ago
Share
Somewhere in the Skies is a weekly podcast covering UFOs and the unexplained. New episodes every Monday. Learn more at: http://www.somewhereintheskies.com
Support this show http://supporter.acast.com/somewhere-in-the-skies.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

18 Episodes
|
Avg Length 56m
|
Latest episode 2 months ago
Share
KIND is a cinematic audio drama best experienced with headphones. For adult audiences only.
Sujin Baek is a happily married cook and caretaker for the children at Eden Orphanage. He is also the Kind Killer, Silver City's most prolific and terrifying serial killer. When his secret is forced to the surface, the city's dark underbelly threatens the very heart and humanity of all Silverians.
Strangekind Studio presents stories that subvert tropes and challenge genre conventions. We spotlight characters who are part of the intersection, including characters who are LGBTQ+, disabled, neurodiverse, and BIPOC. Questions? Comments? Contact us at [email protected] or at our website.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

757 Episodes
|
Avg Length 84m
|
Latest episode 8 hours ago
Share
Do not fear the dark, fear what darkness brings...
Arkham Private Investigator Arthur Lester wakes up with no memory of who he is or what has happened, only a nameless, eerie voice guiding him through the darkness.
Blind, terrified, and confused, his journey will lead him towards a series of mysteries in the hopes of understanding the truth of what has transpired.
As cosmic horrors seep into the world around, Arthur must ask himself whether this entity truly seeks to help him, or are its intentions more...
Malevolent
Malevolent is produced, written, edited, performed, scored & created by Harlan Guthrie.
This podcast contains mature themes, explicit language, bodily horror, violence, otherworldly terror and death. Listener discretion is advised. Full transcripts of every episode are available here.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Each season of Island Crime delves into an unsolved murder or missing person case on Vancouver Island. Host/Producer Laura Palmer updates the cases when she finds new evidence or fresh perspectives. Original journalism, leaving no stone unturned.
Season 7-'Evaporated' explores the disappearance of Victoria's Ian Indridson. Season 6: ‘Sweethearts’ examines the unsolved cases of three teenage girls who were murdered in Victoria, Canada between 1990 and 1991. Season 5: ‘Whiskey Creek’ is the untold story of a Halloween night massacre. Season 4: ‘Finding Amber’ follows the case of a Port Alberni woman who disappeared on July 8, 2022. Season 3: ‘Missing Michael’ is the story of Michael Dunahee, a little boy from Victoria, BC, who vanished from a playground in 1991 at the age of 4. Season 2: ‘Gone Boys’ follows the mystery of men who have gone missing in recent years on Vancouver Island. Season 1: ‘Where is Lisa?’ digs into the disappearance of 21-year-old Lisa Marie Young.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

12 Episodes
|
Avg Length 16m
|
Latest episode 4 years ago
Share

2 Episodes
|
Avg Length 65m
|
Latest episode 2 years ago
Share
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
A murder mystery in neon utopia. An audio drama, by Lux Radium. While ace reporter Nan Kanally and the rest of the world struggle through post-war poverty, Metropolis has assembled a neon utopia on an icy, distant island. It’s an electronic heaven made possible by a fleet of astonishing autonomous robots. But Metropolis holds its secrets tightly. The only word that gets out is from the few reporters they invite. One of them is Nan’s best friend, the sportswriter Stanley Bronfels. But when Stanley disappears, it falls to Nan to discover the secrets of Metropolis... or find oblivion herself.

296 Episodes
|
Avg Length 61m
|
Latest episode 9 days ago
Share
Mystery Podcasts
Unlock your inner detective and grab your magnifying glass because it's time to delve into the world of mystery podcasts on Goodpods! Whether you're a true crime junkie or a fan of unsolved puzzles, these mystery podcasts are sure to keep you on the edge of your seat and leave you questioning everything you thought you knew.
From gruesome murders to unexplained disappearances, from unsolved mysteries to shocking scandals, mystery podcasts cover it all. But be warned - once you start listening, it's hard to stop. You'll find yourself sucked into the twists and turns of each case, eagerly awaiting the next episode to see what new clues or revelations might be uncovered.
Related Fiction Podcast Leaderboards
Top Mystery Podcasts
The best mystery podcasts are expertly produced, well-researched, and full of fascinating stories and intriguing characters. Our listeners have taken the liberty of rating the top mystery podcasts for you. They offer a unique blend of entertainment and education, allowing you to learn about the darker side of human nature while satisfying your thirst for a good old-fashioned whodunit.
What's the best mystery podcast right now in 2025?
Goodpods aggregates the best mystery podcasts people are listening to right now. From mystery fan-favorites to new releases, these shows are guaranteed to be entertaining and informative. Check out the top-rated mystery podcasts in 2025 according to the Goodpods list. Explore our popular categories like Fiction Podcasts, Audit Book Podcasts, and Bigfoot Podcasts.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Best Mystery Podcasts
What are mystery podcasts?
Mystery podcasts are audio programs that focus on exploring and unraveling mysterious and suspenseful stories. They cover a wide range of genres, including true crime, detective stories, paranormal phenomena, unsolved mysteries, and thrilling fictional narratives. These podcasts engage listeners by building suspense, investigating clues, and presenting captivating narratives that keep them on the edge of their seats.
Are mystery podcasts based on real events?
Mystery podcasts can be based on both real events and fictional narratives. True crime mystery podcasts delve into real-life criminal cases and unsolved mysteries, providing detailed accounts and analyses of the events. On the other hand, fictional mystery podcasts create captivating stories and narratives with fictional characters and plotlines. Both types offer engaging and suspenseful content for mystery enthusiasts.
Can you recommend some popular mystery podcasts?
Certainly! Here are a few popular mystery podcasts on Goodpods. "Serial," "My Favorite Murder," "Criminal," "Up and Vanished," "The NoSleep Podcast," "Sword and Scale," "Lore," and "Unsolved Murders: True Crime Stories."
What topics are covered in mystery podcasts?
Mystery podcasts cover a diverse range of topics. True crime podcasts focus on real-life criminal cases, cold cases, serial killers, and unsolved mysteries. Other mystery podcasts explore paranormal phenomena, supernatural events, conspiracy theories, missing-person cases, historical mysteries, and even fictional detective stories. The topics covered depend on the specific focus and theme of each podcast.
Can mystery podcasts be suitable for all audiences?
Mystery podcasts can vary in terms of content and target audience. While some mystery podcasts are suitable for a broad audience, others may contain explicit language, intense descriptions, or graphic details related to crime scenes or disturbing events. It's important to check content ratings, descriptions, or parental guidance recommendations to determine if a particular mystery podcast is appropriate for your age group or personal preferences.
Can mystery podcasts help in solving cold cases or bringing attention to unsolved crimes?
Yes, mystery podcasts have been known to bring attention to cold cases and unsolved crimes, sometimes leading to new information and breakthroughs in investigations. Podcasts that focus on true crime often raise awareness about cold cases, missing persons, or overlooked crimes, potentially prompting listeners to come forward with valuable tips or information.
Are there any psychological effects of listening to mystery podcasts?
Listening to mystery podcasts can evoke various psychological effects in individuals. Some people may experience increased suspense, heightened curiosity, and a sense of engagement as they become absorbed in the storytelling. However, sensitive individuals or those with a history of trauma may find some content distressing or triggering. It's important for listeners to be mindful of their emotional well-being and choose podcasts that align with their comfort levels and personal boundaries.
Can mystery podcasts include interviews or discussions with experts in related fields?
Yes, mystery podcasts often feature interviews or discussions with experts in related fields. True crime podcasts may include interviews with law enforcement professionals, forensic experts, journalists, or individuals involved in specific cases. Paranormal mystery podcasts might invite paranormal investigators, psychics, or researchers to share their insights and experiences. These interviews provide valuable perspectives and expertise that contribute to the overall depth and authenticity of the podcast's content.
Check out these Mystery Podcasts
Months after finding out a friend had disappeared and was presumed dead, the host of the Where The Trail Ends podcast discovered an unplayed voicemail from them. It led to the discovery of recordings that appear to contain evidence of UFO encounters the friend had begun having on hikes. Since then the host has been on a mission to discover the truth about his missing friend and an explanation for the startling evidence that was left behind. And he needs your help...
This unprecedented true UFO crime podcast features our once-skeptical host going down the rabbit hole of the UFO world looking for answers, in a mystery that may change humanity's understanding of this phenomenon.
Please subscribe to the Where The Trail Ends podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/1818933/subscribe
Also be sure to share and follow the podcast on social media and if you have any questions you can email [email protected]
Hosted By: Anonymous
Executive Producer: Ed Peselman
Sound Director: Drew Lagace
Way of the Hermit discusses the Western Esoteric Tradition of Gnosticism, alchemy, Freemasonry, mysticism, Hermetic lore and more. E-mail: [email protected].

492 Episodes
|
Avg Length 36m
|
Latest episode 1 year ago
Share

270 Episodes
|
Avg Length 48m
|
Latest episode 3 days ago
Share

11 Episodes
|
Avg Length 44m
|
Latest episode 5 months ago
Share

26 Episodes
|
Avg Length 17m
|
Latest episode 4 months ago
Share

23 Episodes
|
Avg Length 50m
|
Latest episode 1 year ago
Share
Derek and Cole invite you to join them on the next level of coffee conversations. Enjoying their favorite coffee and cookies while discussing mysteries, murders, and more! Plus the adorable dachshund Onyx is usually there to join in on the fun.

34 Episodes
|
Avg Length 12m
|
Latest episode 15 years ago
Share

37 Episodes
|
Avg Length 41m
|
Latest episode 5 years ago
Share
When Theodore Yates became a doctor, he expected to fight cholera, smallpox, tuberculosis—not an unknown illness that seems to rot people from the inside, including their minds. He finds himself in a race against time to uncover the origin of the Rot and the dark secrets surrounding it, before it's too late for anyone.
The Ichorous Rot is a mysterious historical fiction podcast exploring the long lasting effects of working class exploitation, the ways our families affect us and how those cycles can be broken. Cover art by Moookar
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

22 Episodes
|
Avg Length 19m
|
Latest episode 5 months ago
Share

28 Episodes
|
Avg Length 95m
|
Latest episode 4 years ago
Share

9 Episodes
|
Avg Length 27m
|
Latest episode 6 months ago
Share
A darkly comedic murder mystery podcast telling the story of Quinn Reynolds, a reluctant true-crime celebrity with a violent past. One year into investigating her sister’s murder, Quinn finds her first major lead — reigniting bitter feuds with the media, law enforcement, and an unhinged group of conspiracy theorists.

35 Episodes
|
Avg Length 33m
|
Latest episode 3 years ago
Share

82 Episodes
|
Avg Length 14m
|
Latest episode 5 months ago
Share

51 Episodes
|
Avg Length 22m
|
Latest episode 6 months ago
Share
Every season there's a new mystery.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Tune in for new Bengali audio stories every week. Listen to Bengali stories ranging from – suspense, thriller, horror, mystery, detective and much more.

13 Episodes
|
Avg Length 55m
|
Latest episode 1 year ago
Share
Islands have always been a subject of fascination, often surrounded by myths and legends. In this podcast series, the host takes the audience on a journey exploring various islands, recounting their history, geography, and the stories that have been woven around them. From discovering deserted tropical paradises to delving into the mysteries of ancient civilizations, this podcast covers the allure, beauty, and the enigmatic charm that islands around the world hold in their remote stretches of land and sea.

21 Episodes
|
Avg Length 21m
|
Latest episode 5 months ago
Share

16 Episodes
|
Avg Length 26m
|
Latest episode 6 months ago
Share

67 Episodes
|
Avg Length 43m
|
Latest episode 7 years ago
Share

11 Episodes
|
Avg Length 15m
|
Latest episode 3 years ago
Share