The best podcasts like Small Town Murder

Well, it's simple – Casefile True Crime is like that one friend who always knows the most bone-chilling, jaw-dropping stories you just can't help but listen to. Imagine pulling up a chair on a dark, stormy night and diving deep into some of the most gripping tales of crime, with every fact and detail more gripping than the last. This podcast has a way of grabbing you by the ears and not letting go, with stories ranging from the downright spooky to the unbelievably true. And the best part? You get these stories ad-free and early if you're a subscriber, plus some sweet bonus material. If Small Town Murder is your go-to for true crime with a twist of humor, consider Casefile True Crime its more serious, fact-driven cousin. It’s perfect for those days when you're craving a deep dive into the sinister side of humanity, without any fluff. For fans of the fascinatingly morbid details and the careful tracing of a criminal’s footsteps, it's a match made in, well, not heaven, but you get the point. Give it a listen, and let the mysteries ensnare you! Casefile True Crime is highly recommended if you are looking for a podcast like Small Town Murder.

In crafting this eclectic list of must-hears for fans of "Small Town Murder," our treasure trove simply wouldn't be complete without the dynamic, beer-infused discussions of "True Crime Garage." What sets this podcast apart, and firmly secures its spot on our list, is the unique blend of chilling true crime exploration and lighthearted camaraderie between hosts Nic and the Captain. With each episode, they guide us through the shadowy corridors of true crime, from the mind-boggling unsolved mysteries to the dark tales of notorious serial killers, making us feel like we're just hanging out in the garage with some friends who happen to be experts in true crime lore. If you're riveted by the detailed storytelling and wit found in "Small Town Murder," then "True Crime Garage" will feel like a natural extension of your podcast library. Beyond just the intrigue of each case, it's their approachable and occasionally humorous banter that helps balance the somberness of the topics discussed, making true crime feel more accessible to all. So, grab your favorite cold one, and dive into this treasure trove of true crime stories – where the only rule is to not take yourself too seriously. True Crime Garage is highly recommended if you are looking for a podcast like Small Town Murder.

If you can't get enough of the blend of dark humor and true crime that "Small Town Murder" serves up, then "Crime in Sports" is practically tailor-made for you. This podcast takes the recipe of combining laughter with lawbreaking and applies it to the world of sports, giving it a unique twist that stands out in the true crime genre. The hosts, with their sharp wit, dive deep into the stories of athletes who've stumbled from the spotlight into the police lights, doing so with an energy and humor that keeps you hooked from start to finish. Their thorough research shines through, ensuring you're not just entertained but also well-informed. So, for fans of "Small Town Murder" looking for a new angle on crime, spiced up with a healthy dose of comedy, "Crime in Sports" will not disappoint. It's the perfect blend of sports, scandal, and satire, making it a slam dunk (or home run, touchdown, you name it) addition to your podcast playlist. Crime in Sports is highly recommended if you are looking for a podcast like Small Town Murder.

If you're someone who finds the spine-chilling tales of Small Town Murder irresistibly intriguing, then strapping in for an episode of Last Podcast On The Left is like grabbing a ticket to the horror genre's wildest ride. This podcast is a treasure trove of the macabre, delving into the darkest corners of our world with a mix of deep research, gripping storytelling, and an unexpectedly hilarious twist. The hosts cover a broad spectrum of topics, from notorious serial killers and eerie unsolved mysteries to full-blown supernatural phenomena and obscure cults. What sets it apart is the unique blend of humor and horror – a concoction that keeps the topics engaging without underplaying their seriousness. For fans of Small Town Murder looking to explore the depths of human nature (and beyond) with a side of laughter, Last Podcast On The Left promises a thrilling adventure. Its ability to present grim tales with levity makes it a perfect companion podcast, ensuring that your fascination with the darker side of life is continually fed with well-researched content and a fun twist. Last Podcast On The Left is highly recommended if you are looking for a podcast like Small Town Murder.

Why did we choose this podcast, you ask? Well, because we simply can’t resist the gritty and the real, the kind of stories that make your spine tingle and your mind whirl. Sword and Scale takes true crime to another level, delving into the darkest corners of human behavior with a rawness that’s both shocking and compelling. This isn’t your average detective story; it’s a deep dive into the complexities of crime and justice, narrated in a way that feels chillingly personal. The inclusion of actual 911 calls, court testimonies, and even interactions with those involved in the cases provides an immersive experience that’s hard to shake off. For fans of Small Town Murder who thrive on the mix of humor and horror in the exploration of heinous crimes, Sword and Scale offers a more intense but equally engaging perspective on the reality of human nature’s darkest aspects. It’s not just about the crimes, but about understanding the people behind them and the society that surrounds them. If you’re fascinated by the intricacies of criminal minds and the stories beyond the headlines, this podcast is an absolute must-listen. Trust us, once you start, you’ll be hooked on the gripping tales that Sword and Scale has to offer. Sword and Scale is highly recommended if you are looking for a podcast like Small Town Murder.