Log in

goodpods headphones icon

To access all our features

Open the Goodpods app
Close icon
Amanda and Cassidy's profile image
share icon

Share

The best podcasts for Mystery and Paranormal fans

share icon

Share

Who am I?

We love anything weird, unexplained, or down right scary! That's why we started Drinking the Koolaid which covers two stories a week and starts with some fun banter and comedy. We can never find enough spooky content, so we would love to help others find podcasts they love too!

My Show

What is my podcast about and/or how does it relate to the playlist topic you chose?

Drinking the Koolaid is a comedy podcast dedicated to the mysterious. We cover everything from true crime to alien abductions and everything in between.

What is my podcast playlist about?

This podcast playlist is perfect for anyone looking for spooky, mysterious, weird, or wild stories! Including both fiction and nonfiction stories this list has something for everyone!

The podcasts I picked and why

1. Odd Trails

Why this podcast?

This is the perfect show to hear real life experiences with strange and potentially paranormal happenings. Straight forward story telling with no fluff!

Odd Trails

Odd Trails

Cryptic County

play

Play first episode

Odd Trails is an anthology of true paranormal stories, narrated by Andy Tate and Brandon Lanier. Join us every week as we dive into all things weird and otherworldly. Submit your experiences to [email protected].

profile image
profile image

10 Listeners

comment icon

1 Comment

1

bookmark
share podcast

2. Otherworld

Why this podcast?

This podcast shares some of the most wild real life paranormal stories around. The host is a great interviewer and keeps you captivated the whole time!

Otherworld

Otherworld

Otherworld

play

Play first episode

Otherworld tells real stories of people who have experienced something paranormal or unexplainable. Host Jack Wagner takes an open minded and journalistic approach to the subject matter and aims to uncover some of the biggest mysteries of the world and how people react to it.

profile image

6 Listeners

bookmark
share podcast

3. Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast

Why this podcast?

Real, scary, encounters that people have where it seemed like things could have gone very wrong. ASMR style soothing narration.

Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast
play

Play first episode

True horror stories written by those who made it out alive. First-person accounts narrated and produced by Andy Tate in an anthology of terror and suspense. To hear your story on the show, send it to [email protected]

profile image

36 Listeners

comment icon

2 Comments

2

bookmark
share podcast

4. Welcome to Night Vale

Why this podcast?

Funny, witty, and spooky this NPR style fiction pod about the very strange town of Nightvale is a perfect light listen for anyone who loves strange storytelling.

Welcome to Night Vale

Welcome to Night Vale

Night Vale Presents

play

Play first episode

Twice-monthly community updates for the small desert town of Night Vale, where every conspiracy theory is true. Turn on your radio and hide. Never listened before? It's an ongoing radio show. Start with the current episode, and you'll catch on in no time. Or, go right to Episode 1 if you wanna binge-listen.

profile image
profile image

55 Listeners

comment icon

4 Comments

4

bookmark
share podcast

5. Morbid

Why this podcast?

With hilarious banter and captivating stories this podcast is always a win. It's a fan favorite for a reason!

Morbid

Morbid

Morbid Network | Wondery

play

Play first episode

It’s a lighthearted nightmare in here, weirdos! Morbid is a true crime, creepy history and all things spooky podcast hosted by an autopsy technician and a hairstylist. Join us for a heavy dose of research with a dash of comedy thrown in for flavor.

profile image
profile image

255 Listeners

comment icon

8 Comments

8

bookmark
share podcast

The best podcasts for...

View all

Podcasters, experts, and listeners pick a theme and share their 5 favorite podcasts



















  • View lists in the same categories