
Serial Strangler: Herbert Baumeister
02/24/23 • 62 min
Episode #18
On the surface, Herb Baumeister was a dedicated family man and a successful entrepreneur. He donated to charities, and had a good standing in the community...depending who you asked.
Herb was also a weird guy with antisocial behavior. In his youth, he played pranks with dead birds and pissed on a teacher's desk. In fact, he pissed on a lot of things which amounted to him being fired from a well paying job.
When a full human skeleton was found on Herb's property, he managed to explain it away, but as time wore on, a private investigator and a police detective suspect that Herb Baumeister is responsible for the disappearances of gay men around Indianapolis.
What is uncovered on Herbert Baumeister's property is nothing short of horrific. You won't want to miss this episode.
Hosted by Bob Macumber
Episode #18
On the surface, Herb Baumeister was a dedicated family man and a successful entrepreneur. He donated to charities, and had a good standing in the community...depending who you asked.
Herb was also a weird guy with antisocial behavior. In his youth, he played pranks with dead birds and pissed on a teacher's desk. In fact, he pissed on a lot of things which amounted to him being fired from a well paying job.
When a full human skeleton was found on Herb's property, he managed to explain it away, but as time wore on, a private investigator and a police detective suspect that Herb Baumeister is responsible for the disappearances of gay men around Indianapolis.
What is uncovered on Herbert Baumeister's property is nothing short of horrific. You won't want to miss this episode.
Hosted by Bob Macumber
Previous Episode

The Treehouse Murder: Julia Enright
Episode #17
Happy Valentine's Day, ya filthy animals!!!
What is the best present someone can give to their true love? How about a dead body or human blood for a bubble bath?
Julia Enright loved Brandon Chicklis in a special kind of way. She loved to hate him. They had dated in the past, but it didn't work out because Julia loved to play mind games. She also loved making art with animal bones, blood play, BDSM, and had a side hustle as a dominatrix.
On June 23rd, 2018, Brandon Chicklis was reported missing and when his body is discovered almost 3 weeks later, police have one prime suspect: Julia Enright.
Hosted by Bob Macumber
Next Episode

Montreal Massacre: Marc Lepine
Episode #19
On December 6th, 1989, Marc Lepine walked into Ecole Polytechnique armed with a semi-automatic weapon. Lepine would commit one of the worst mass shootings in Canadian history, but what motivated him to target engineering students? Why did he want them dead?
We will explore Lepine's f*cked up childhood all the way to the moment he decided to pick up a gun and kill.
There's some wild twists and turns , so sit back and brace yourself for this episode.
Hosted by Bob Macumber
If you like this episode you’ll love
Episode Comments
Generate a badge
Get a badge for your website that links back to this episode
<a href="https://goodpods.com/podcasts/beyond-the-macabre-249612/serial-strangler-herbert-baumeister-28651408"> <img src="https://storage.googleapis.com/goodpods-images-bucket/badges/generic-badge-1.svg" alt="listen to serial strangler: herbert baumeister on goodpods" style="width: 225px" /> </a>
Copy